MovieChat Forums > 3:10 to Yuma (1957) Discussion > Name your favorite westerns.......NOBODY...

Name your favorite westerns.......NOBODY under 50 need answer!


I'm waiting.......

reply

Here's a few, in no particular order (highlighting stars I enjoyed):

Movies -
The Big Country (Burl Ives, Charlton Heston, Gregory Peck)
The Magnificent Seven (Brynner, McQueen, Coburn)
The Hanging Tree (Scott, Malden, Cooper)
The Fastest Gun Alive (Glenn Ford)
3:10 to Yuma (Glenn Ford)
Tombstone (Val Kilmer)
Silverado (all)
The Wild Bunch
Quick and the Dead
Butch Cassidy & Sundance Kid
Rio Bravo
Quigley Down Under
Any western with Tom Selleck or Sam Elliott

Television -
Have Gun Will Travel
Bat Masterson
Bonanza
Gunsmoke
The Big Valley
Yantze Derringer
Rawhide
The Rifleman

That should get you started...If I review the appropriate lists I could name another 50 I've seen but I'll leave those for others.





reply

No " Shane "? How about " The Shootist "? To mention a couple. Remember...I said nobody under 50.

reply

For some reason, I've never seen "Shane". Shane on me.
"The Shootist" was good, but I've never been a huge John Wayne fan, because the only character he ever played was "John Wayne". I suppose that's sacrilegious.
fyi, I was born in the first half of the 20th century, i. e. before television sets were widely available.

Maybe respondents should also name the absolute "best western" ever made.

My brother, born during WWII, definitively assures me it was "The Big Country".
He discounts the Magnificent Seven because he believes each of the characters were playing caricatures of the actors themselves.

I also forgot to mention "Warlock", a great Henry Fonda/Anthony Quinn film. I also loved "Gettysburg" which was actually a war movie but still in the western time period.

Best acting in a western film...had to be Val Kilmer in Tombstone.

Too bad they cancelled the Deadwood TV program...it was probably more true to life than Hollywood's films.

reply

[deleted]

Doogiebee, I clicked on your user name so that I could send you a private message and IMDB came back with the message " that user does not exist ". What gives?

reply

Every morning when I get up, the first thing I do is read the obituary column in the Toronto Star to see if I'm listed as "deceased".
So far, so good, so I think I still exist.
I'll send a notice to the IMDB of your advisement, and would love to receive my first private message (assuming it doesn't contain anthrax).

reply

[deleted]

I'm 51
THE FAR COUNTRY
THE SEARCHERS
COLORADO SUNDOWN (Rex Allen, but so what?)
BEND OF THE RIVER
TRUE GRIT
UNFORGIVEN
THE SHOOTIST
UNION PACIFIC
STAGECOACH
MY DARLING CLEMENTINE
MAN WHO SHOT LIBERTY VALANCE
SHANE
THE PROFESSIONALS

reply

MCCABE AND MRS. MILLER (BY A MILE)
THE OUTLAW JOSEY WALES
LONESOME DOVE (TV MINISERIES)
SHANE
HIGH NOON

reply

One Eyed Jacks is missing on your list.



You big tub of guts.

reply

Oh, man! You gotta see Shane! That's like being a Beatles fan but not having heard Sgt. Pepper.

reply

so anyone under 50 doesn't know anything about westerns?

so then the shootist,rio lobo,rooster cogburn,red river,north to alaska,the man who shot liberty valance,and all those other great John Wayne films that are to many to mention would escape my appreciation?

or maybe,high noon,billy the kid,magnificent seven,how the west was won,once up on a time in the west, are just to classic for me.

forget about the clint eastwood westerns of which i have seen all many times,including the rawhide years.

speaking of rawhide,i guess the virginian,wanted dead or alive,zane grey theatre,
gunsmoke,even to big valley and bonanza,and who can forget maverick? of course all these have escaped me.

maybe i'm to young to realize there was westerns before lonseome dove, dances with wolves,and Geronimo(the new one not the one burt lancaster played in).

how could i ever have known that Glenn Ford,Kirk Douglas,Randolph Scott,Henry Fonda,John Carradine,Eli Wallach all had good careers in westerns.

i sure wish i hadn't have been to young to have read and enjoyed a lot of louis l' amour paperbacks,i'm sure i missed out not getting to read the sackett novels.which didnt they make a movie on in the 80's? i'm sure it was ok but never got close to the thrill of the Tennessee sacketts in the novels.

forgive us young whooper snappers for not knowing good westerns like you old longtooth guys do,but then maybe an extra 20 years of watching westerns is all you really have on us.
hopefully in the next 20 years i can find all those missing classics i haven't saw,but after viewing all the ones i named above and more, i doubt there is much better out there :D

reply

I'm 52,I liked all those listed before,also The Ox Bow Incident,Silverado,Support Your Local Sheriff,Hombre,The Wild Bunch,Judge Roy Bean,Stagecoach,etc.

reply

I'm 56. My top 5:

The Outlaw Josey Wales
Ride the High Country
The Alamo (John Wayne version)
3:10 to Yuma
The Proud Rebel

reply

I'm 25. My top 5 favorites are:

High Noon
Big Jake
The Man Who Shot Liberty Vallance
The Cowboys
True Grit

Runner ups?

The Shootist
The Magnificent Seven
The Big Country
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
Fist Full of Dollars
Open Range
Silverado
Back to the Future III (hehe yeah I know)
Unforgiven
and of course now 3:10 to Yuma
and many many others that I'm just not remembering right now.

"I'm not here to talk about what I think about you." - A.D. Skinner

reply

For all the times us youth have been called ageists....

I'm 25 but I hope that I've seen my fair share of Westerns...at least when compared to my generational colleagues.

So let me say this...Once Upon a Time in the West, The Searchers, Stagecoach...The Outlaw Josey Wales, Fistful of Dollars, Tombstone.

I've seen a fair amount of others.

reply

[deleted]

In no particular order.

The Hanging Tree
Man of the West
The Missing
Open Range
Red River
The Searchers
Shane
and naturally the original 3:10 to Yuma

Waffles Anyone
rstory-3
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=28764731

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

On the contrary, you do matter, but only for 2 of your choices. You can probably guess which ones I agree with.

reply

Hi, I’m not gonna be fifty for a while yet, but I’d like to weigh in.

The Big Country (Gregory Peck, Charlton Heston)
Destry (Audie Murphy)
Destry Rides Again (James Stewart)
El Dorado (John Wayne, Robert Mitchum)
Gunfight at the OK Corral (Kirk Douglas, Burt Lancaster)
The Hanging Tree (Gary Cooper)
High Noon (Gary Cooper)
How The West Was Won (the Jimmy Stewart segment is my favorite)
The Man From Laramie (Jimmy Stewart)
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (John Wayne, Jimmy Stewart)
The Outlaw Josey Wales (Clint Eastwood)
The Proud Rebel (Alan Ladd)
Ride the High Country (Joel McCrea, Randolph Scott)
Rio Bravo (John Wayne, Dean Martin)
Shane (Alan Ladd)
The Tall T (Randolph Scott)
3:10 to Yuma (Glenn Ford, Van Heflin)
Winchester ‘73 (Jimmy Stewart)

Out of that list, my all time favorites are Shane, The Hanging Tree, and 3:10 to Yuma. Which might not exactly be true - I think whichever one of the above I happen to be watching at the time is my favorite lol.

I have to confess that even though Tall T is my favorite western with Randolph Scott, I think any western he made was a classic.

Also - did you know that Jimmy Stewart appeared in a western radio show in the late 50's called “The Six Shooter?” I’ve bought some copies of the show, and it’s really wonderful.

- Marty

There’s NOTHING like a great western.

reply

Marty, Not a bad list at all. Very glad to see that you didn't have any spaghetti westerns on the list. I'm glad that you've included " The Tall T ". Randolph Scott's films need to be given more attention. Check out " Seven Men From Now " and " Ride Lonesome ", also. If I may make a suggestion, please check out " The Ox-bow Incident ". It's the only western that ever brought tears to my eyes. Don't forget to listen to the voice over commentary.

reply

[deleted]

You watch what you like and I'll watch what I like. Fair enough?

reply

Hi Srklondie -

Thanks for the tip - I have actually seen Ox-Bow Incident, but a long time ago when I was a kid, so I don't remember too much about it, I'll have to watch it again - Dana Andrews is one of my favorites.

Here's an interesting bit of trivia. I was a preteen in the 70's and loved old movies. There was a book in the school library called "Who's Who in America" that not only listed alot of old time stars, but their addresses as well. So I wrote to a LOT of them and asked for their autographs - I included a piece of my personalized note paper and a stamped, self addressed envelope. So I got personalized autographs from alot of golden age of Hollywood stars, including people like Groucho Marx and Fred Astaire, but for the purposes of our discussion, the western stars I received autographs from include:

Dana Andrews
John Carradine
Joel McCrea
Henry Fonda
Charlton Heston
Jimmy Stewart
Robert Mitchum
Joseph Cotten (Duel in the Sun)
Victor Mature (My Darling Clementine)
Dean Martin (Rio Bravo)
Gregory Peck
John Agar

A very fun hobby, and actually I still do it every once in a while.

Best regards -

reply

Very nice. You have quite a collection there.

reply

[deleted]

I think that you're mistaking me for another poster. I've seen virtually every spaghetti western on the lists posters have made and they just don't appeal to me. Sorry. As for my own list; well, you haven't seen that yet.

reply

[deleted]

Closed-minded is passing judgment on something you haven't seen. I've seen most every one of them and they just don't appeal to me. Why is it that just because I don't agree with you, you feel that you have the right to question my judgment? You must have a terrible time going through life, questioning the judgment of those who don't agree with you. I feel bad for you and for anyone who has to deal with you. I imagine the first adjective that your acquaintances use to describe you is ' spoiled '. How old are you, by the way? 25 would be my guess.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Why don't you just go play in the traffic. In other words, pester someone else.

reply

[deleted]

I don't understand your question. Please be specific.

reply

[deleted]

I have over 200 westerns on DVD,i've seen a hell of a lot more,and i'd love to tell you my favourites.............



.........but i'm only 40

"Cowboys don't get married....unless they stop being cowboys" Monte Walsh(1970)

reply

My Papaw was a huge western fan before he died...so I watched a lot with him growing up...but I'm only 20, so I guess my favorites don't count...

reply

I'll make an exception. Give me your top ten.

reply

Off the top of my head ;

Monte Walsh(1970)
The Gunfighter
Once Upon A Time In The West
Seven Men From Now
Yellow Sky
The Searchers
The Ox-Bow Incident
Jeremiah Johnson
The Tall T
Ride The High Country

Special mention to McCabe & Mrs Miller,The Fastest Gun Alive,Devils Doorway(and most of the other Mann westerns),3:10 To Yuma,Day Of The Outlaw all the 'Ranowns' and many more.
As i said,this is off the top of my head,and changes with my mood.Interested to know what you think.

"Cowboys don't get married....unless they stop being cowboys" Monte Walsh(1970)

reply

[deleted]

Them's fightin' words! You gonna draw them pistols or just whistle Dixie?

reply

I think that you're mistaking me for another poster. I've seen virtually every spaghetti western on the lists posters have made and they just don't appeal to me. Sorry. As for my own list; well, you haven't seen that yet.

reply

Bet those are worth some money. I wrote Margaret O'Brien once but she never wrote me back (little brat).

reply

Looks like you were a Jimmy Stewart fan. Me too. I miss him.

reply

[deleted]

3:10 To Yuma (1957)
The Searchers
The Wild Bunch
High Noon
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
Rio Bravo
The Ox Bow Incident
The Gunfighter
For a Few Dollars More

Im not 50 but dont care when people try to divide people up according to silly imaginary settings.

reply

Glad you put " Ox-Bow " in there. Not many people do. It's my favorite western and is in my top ten list.

reply

If you're going lecture the OP against "divisive" thread making, then you should seek out the insane amount of teenager-started threads asking for "other teens who enjoy movie?" and also tell those posters cut their bullsh**. Teens are the masters of trying to monopolize these forums for age-divisive discussions. Do young people not get enough attention on the website that it has to be considered so horribly offensive the rare time that older posters attempt to borrow some forum space for themselves? Also, what's the "imaginary setting" you're referring to? Is it age that you're referring to as imaginary?

For the record, this coming from someone in her 20s. I love old westerns and have a great list of them, but am willing to respect the wishes that the OP made in HIS thread and not post mine. I'm not that insecure or attention-hungry as to not be aware I have the option plenty of other threads I can post a list on (including ones I can start myself).

reply

Smile when you call me that.

reply

Unforgiven
Good, Bad and Ugly
Once Upon a Time in West
Little Big Man
Soldier Blue
Apache
The Proposition
Wild Bunch
Butch Cassiddy and The Sundance Kid
Young Guns
Silverado
Wyatt Earp
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
For A Few Dollars More
Outlaw Josey Walles
3:10 to Yuma

reply

I KNOOOW you're not 50. In fact, I'll bet you're not 30.

reply