MovieChat Forums > The Teahouse of the August Moon Discussion > Louis Calhern and the MGM promo short

Louis Calhern and the MGM promo short


As most people know, MGM contract player Louis Calhern was to co-star in The Teahouse of the August Moon, in the role of Col. Purdy. He went to Japan with the rest of the cast but a month later died suddenly of a heart attack. With his scenes uncompleted and needing to get a replacement quickly, MGM made the sensible decision to hire Paul Ford, who had created the part on Broadway and obviously knew it backward, to take over the role in the movie. At this time Ford had very few films to his credit and Teahouse was a major boost to his career.

All well and good, but MGM did a promotional short (plus a newsreel) about the making of the movie, which included shots of the cast arriving in Japan, where they were driven into a crowd of Japanese waving signs reading "Welcome Marlon Brando", "Welcome Glenn Ford", and so on -- Welcome to Eddie Albert, Harry Morgan, even to MGM. And in amongst the signs, plainly visible, is another one reading "Welcome Louis Calhern". By the time these shorts were ready to be played in theaters, Calhern had died and Paul Ford was in, yet no mention or sight of Calhern is made in either. Any pictures of or references to him were simply cut out. There was nothing they could do about his Welcome sign bobbing up and down amid all the rest, except hope people wouldn't notice, but every other step was taken to obliterate any indication that Louis Calhern was to have been in the film, much less that he had died.

This was typical of Hollywood in those days, where things such as the death of a performer were never mentioned in any publicity, or certainly in the film itself (as is often done today, with a deceased individual's name shown "In Memory Of" at the end). But it was a shameful practice. Metro could at least have made a fond mention of the late actor and been up front about what had happened. But the studios were petrified of anything that would indicate any flaw or tragedy in the fairy tale.

I wonder what Calhern would have been like in the role. He did film much of it, but presumably any footage of him has long since been discarded or allowed to disintegrate.

reply

Now that you mention it, I wonder, too...

reply

But it was a shameful practice. Metro could at least have made a fond mention of the late actor and been up front about what had happened.
Yes, well said hobnob. 🐭

reply

Thanks, spooky. Yes, God forbid that anything real intrude upon the lightness and fantasy. I really wonder how many people in theaters in 1956 noticed the Calhern signs and even thought about them.

reply

Hobnob, this just happened to fall into my lap, just after you replied. Compare the difference.
http://thenewdaily.com.au/entertainment/2016/04/06/the-jungle-book-movie-review/
SR🐭

reply

Yeah, not really that close. Of course, there have been many actors who have died while or right after making a film, and not simply as cartoon voices. That's a much bigger deal than Garry Shandling's sad loss.

I've seen promos for this new version of The Jungle Book and it looks stupid and inane -- in other words, right up today's kids' alleys.

reply

He was at the peak of his career when he passed away. Back in those days before bypass surgery we lost so many stars in their 40s and 50s to coronary artery disease. Now a man like Louis could have another 20 -30 years.

reply

Well, he was 61 and a heavy smoker, so obviously none of that helped. I doubt he'd have lived another 20 (and almost certainly not 30) years longer even today (age 81 maybe, age 91 very unlikely), but surely he might have gotten another 10 or 15.

The same holds true of other stars who died relatively young of heart attacks in that era: John Hodiak in 1955 at 41, character actor James Millican in 1955 at 44, Tyrone Power in 1958 at 44, Paul Douglas in 1959 at 52, Errol Flynn in 1959 at 50, Clark Gable in 1960 at 59, Frank Lovejoy in 1962 at 50, to name a few. I once read that 1958 was the peak year for heart attacks in the U.S., and the deaths of so many actors from coronary issues in that period seems to support this broader fact. What's also notable about most of these people is that, like Louis Calhern, they were all very heavy smokers. (In a great irony, not long before he died, Power recorded an ad for the American Heart Association urging people to get enough rest to avoid heart attacks -- more proof that no one was getting at the real problems behind the growing rate of coronary issues in the U.S.)

Unfortunately today we can treat most diseases far more effectively, and have much better knowledge of preventive measures and healthier living, than was possible 60 years ago -- or even 10 or 20. Sadly, many, probably most, people in earlier eras died sooner than they probably would have had they lived in medically more advanced times. That's just the normal history of mankind, and still is. I'm sure people are dying of things today that 50 or 100 years from now will be routinely curable.

reply