MovieChat Forums > Moby Dick (1956) Discussion > JAWS, Orca or Moby Dick?

JAWS, Orca or Moby Dick?


I ignore (tell me if you know) if Spielberg studied Huston's Moby Dick epic or not but I see some similarities beyond the obvious fact is a sea-monster film. The main probably the fact we see the beast in few ocassions like homeopathic dosage. There's a lot of talking about how dangerous the animal could be or stories from the past. Yet in Orca (was that the name of the film with Richard Harris when he was still blonde?)we see the "thinking" beast more than in Jaws, the vengeful creature. The shark is a killing machine "per se" but doesn't "reason" like the white spermwhale or the killer whale.
Spielberg gives attention to the oceanographer's ship and old captain's ship in the same way Huston paid detailed attention to the huge vessel.
There are some unforgettable scenes in my mind from Moby Dick, the bearded old woman among the crowd saying goodbye to the crew; St. Elmo's Fire, the turmoil of the water after the ship sinks, Ahab's dead body waving his arm attached to the monster; the prophecy of the man with vivid eyes; the listening of Ahab's stroll before we actually see him, one-legget tall man with a beard without mustouche and that Lincolnesque's hat. What a wonderful experience when I saw it the first time in my youth decades before making a line to see Jaws at the movie theatre!

reply

Jaws bears similarities to several literary and artistic works, most notably Moby-Dick by Herman Melville. The character of Quint strongly resembles Captain Ahab, the obsessed captain of the Pequod who devotes his life to hunting a sperm whale. Quint's monologue reveals his similar vendetta against sharks, and even his boat, the Orca, is named after the only natural enemy of sharks. In the novel and original screenplay, Quint dies after being dragged under the ocean by a harpoon tied to his leg, similar to Ahab's death in Melville's novel. A direct reference to these similarities may be found in the original screenplay, which introduced Quint by showing him watching the film version of Moby-Dick. His laughter throughout makes people get up and leave the theater (Wesley Strick's screenplay for Cape Fear features a similar scene). However, the scene from Moby-Dick could not be licensed from Gregory Peck, the owner of the rights. The final scenes of the film, in which the men chase the shark and try to harpoon it with flotation barrels, parallel the chase for Moby-Dick in the novel.

reply

Herman Melville based this on a true incident.

reply