Female MiG pilot?


The Soviets in the movie come off as being inept and comical. The movie, made at the height of anti-Soviet paranoia in America, trots out many Russian stereotypes.

However, it does cast a female as a MiG pilot. What does this say for an American movie maker to write this? Is the pilot herself a stereotype? Remember, in the U.S. at the time, women could get work as teachers, nurses, and secretaries, and that was about it. A pilot? Not a chance. But here we have a woman as a Top Gun fighter.

What are we 21st Century viewers to make of this? Is it a caricature? Or a statement regarding the poor lot of women in the workforce of the 50s? And how common was a female MiG pilot anyway?


- - -

"...and that, my liege, is how we know the Earth to be banana shaped."

reply

The Soviets definitely had women pilots by then, even back in WWII. I don't think it was anything but a plot device to explain Hepburn's entry into the west. Followed by lots of feminist dialog like, "I don't like women in uniform. I don't know whether to kiss 'em or salute 'em.".

reply

At the time it was a given--the Soviet Union had women in their military and they kicked butt (both the military and the women).

I was going to write up an extensive discussion, but Woody Guthrie sums it up far better than i can: youtube.com/watch?v=SHKjOl9ocR0.

And here's a look at the real deal--not a pilot, but a the sniper Woody was singing about: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDO6n7GuslA.

reply

The US has had all kinds of female pilots, civil and military. Still does.

Stop trying to make the US some kind of freakish misogynistic nation. The US leads almost all nations in social rights/privileges, including women's rights.

Wanna see authentic misogyny? Go visit some Islamic nations.

reply

There might not have been any US fighter pilots in 1956 but I bet there have been US fighter pilots for decades... wait ... what's that? Only one complete decade has passed since Jeannie Leavitt became the US's first fighter pilot.

I bet you cannot find a predominately Muslim populated country having a very long history of female fighter pilots... wait a minute .. what's that? Turkey, where over 98% of the population is Muslim, produced the world's first fighter pilot in 1937 in the shape of Sabiha Gökçen.

Russia has the world's longest history of female military pilots but you cannot thank communism for that. Their history began in Czarist Russia in 1914 when Eugenie Mikhailovna Shakhovskaya began flying reconnaissance missions.

Although there was not an official segregation policy, female fighter pilots only came to the fore with the formation of the Night Witches and other all-female fighter squadrons in World War II. I imagine that the history of female fighter pilots did continue but it seems that a combination of height restrictions and the resurfacing of chauvinism in the 1950s meant that there might not have been quite so many by 1956.

There were certainly female pilots of the Mig-21 that was introduced in 1959 but I cannot find any that flew M-19s before that as of yet so it would seem that female MiG fighter pilots were quite rare when the film was made.

I suspect that future audiences will recognize that women did not have equal rights for much of the 20th century but with a bit of research should find out that the deprivation of roles for women in the US disappeared in 1993 ... unless you were a lesbian. 1993 was the year that saw Kara Hultgreen become a Tomcat pilot.

I don't think the original poster was looking for misogyny per se, the OP just wanted to ask about what this film might say of about the US or the West of the 20th century in the future.

reply

The filmmakers weren't concerned with whether there actually were female Soviet fighter pilots or not. It was a plot device, pure and simple.

But if looked at from the mentality of its era, the notion of a woman being a jet pilot was obviously meant to suggest that the Russians had no concept of women as "the gentle sex", but looked at them merely as sexless, humorless comrades doing men's work. It was intended as a disparaging joke, much like the depiction of female Russian dock workers at the end of the 1943 film Action in the North Atlantic -- making fun of the Soviets as ideologues intent, among other things, on deglamorizing women.

It's true, especially under Stalin, that the Soviet regime suppressed art, literature or then-popular concepts like "free love" that emphasized sexuality (men's as well as women's), and the fact that women were used in many occupations usually thought of as "men's work" in the West was viewed as evidence of the regime's failures and desperation. The Soviets were also notoriously prudish, and sex education, and even clinical knowledge about sex, were virtually non-existent under the Soviets. So the caricature played by Katharine Hepburn fit right in with popular (and condescending) western beliefs about Russian women, though like all caricatures there was also some truth to the image.

Hepburn's character says as much about the smirking attitudes towards women in the West so widely held in the 1950s, as it does about the supposed equality of women under the rigid, corrupt and inefficient Soviet system. But at the time western audiences, who were the only people who would ever see this film -- if indeed anyone went to see it -- would have regarded Hepburn's falling for Hope, discovering sex and glamor, and giving up her skills to settle down with an idiot, as the natural state of affairs for a woman.

reply

Jeannie Levitt was the first female active-duty combat fighter pilot; during WWII, there were more than 1100 Women Airforce Service Pilots--WASPs--trained to perform jobs that freed up men to fight overseas. These included ferrying new aircraft from factories to bases and ports, testing repaired aircraft, and towing targets for ground and aerial gunnery training. They were, unfortunately not permitted to actually join the Air Force and only recognized as military members retroactively, in the mid-1970s.

My impression was that Hepburn's character had a similar role; not a combat pilot (although there were female Soviet combat pilots during the desperate days of WWII) but perhaps with a propaganda element, like Hanna Reitsch in Germany.

reply

The only "Russian" I found at all convincing was
Colonel Sklarnoff (James Robertson Justice). He actujally comes across as a real threat and villain.

Had this film been a serious drama,his role would have been better recievced.


You can find him as "Jensen" in The Guns Of Navarrone".



MAN! One dream's come true,ready for another.
🐕 (MR.) happipuppi13 🐕 *arf,man!*!

reply