MovieChat Forums > Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) Discussion > Is it me, or does this movie stop making...

Is it me, or does this movie stop making sense after the second act?


Okay, it's been awhile since I saw this, so my memory's a bit foggy...but the pod clones don't make sense. The movie sets up the premise that people are being replaced with the pod clones, right? But then in the last act, it's shown that all the aliens have to do is just wait for someone to fall asleep to take over their original bodies. Was this just a writing goof?

reply

pods are necessary to replace humans. the replacement process takes place while humans are sleeping.

reply

I just saw the movie again this past week. It seems as if the writers goofed.

In an earlier scene, the characters say that the pods themselves are what replace the human beings. When they completely form and come alive, the original body of the person it was meant to replace disintegrates.

But then in the last act, the movie shows the opposite happening. The original human body remains alive. It's just that the pod clone transfers itself into the original person when he or she falls asleep.

reply

I just watched it again and I see how you would think that. The Becky clone tells Miles she went to sleep and it happened. Then in the narrative, Miles says a moment of sleep caused him to lose Becky. The transformation was really fast and where was the pod?

reply

I am confused because they show the pods creating a new clone in that garden.

So how come Dana Wynter, at the end of the movie, changed to one of them when she fell asleep in the tunnel? That means there could be two versions of yourself walking around? The latter movies always established the original host would shrivel and die as it is no longer useful.

reply

they went for the dramatics and had him kiss the clone. they didn't show the transformation process in the 1956 version.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WuL2QwsNeM8

reply

I thought a pod would have to be placed nearby for it to happen. But it seems some users here (the more I'm reading around) have the theory a pod was probably placed nearby by the mob earlier.

That's quite a fast transformation, but as you said they were probably going for dramatics. Still quite chilling to see her completely change like that.

reply

she's also fully dressed. they couldn't have any hint of nudity in 1956.

reply

Yeah. I think that is a legit problem.

They were in that cave-tunnel when Dany Wynter falls asleep, and in a matter of moments she becomes a pod person. Where did her replacement body come from? It's not explained in the movie, and I can't come up with one either.

reply


Yes, it's you, hon.

reply

Scene in garden: "What happens to the original bodies?" "I guess they must disintegrate." (Establishing that the pods are what replace the human bodies.)

Scene in cave: "It happens when you sleep." (Establishing that her body was never replaced by any pod, that a consciousness was transferred instead, since she expressed exhaustion the entire time while trying to escape the townspeople.)

reply