MovieChat Forums > The Catered Affair (1956) Discussion > Rod Taylor and Debbie Reynolds

Rod Taylor and Debbie Reynolds


Rod Taylor and Debbie Reynolds both made me cry in this beautiful gem of a film. There existed some pure poetry in the script (most of it spoken by Reynolds and Taylor), aided further by astonishing acting.

Rod Taylor: One of my all-time favorite actors (I could watch and listen to him read the phone book) Once again, he does an amazing American accent, which is not easy (not even the equally-as-talented Michael Caine can com CLOSE). Rod blew me away here. Late in the film when they are in his apartment lying on the bed, to listen to him and watch him -- words fail me. Flawless. I cried when he spoke about 'what love was' (is), it was far and away one of the most touching, lovely scenes I have ever seen. I doubt I will ever forget it, it evoked such deep feelings in me.

Debbie Reynolds: Was also perfect in this -- hell, EVERY scene of this film. A very true, honest portrayal in what may have been a difficult role. She made it look effortless, taking complete command the part. For one so young, she certainly gave a thoughtful, mature performance. She made me cry in the avbove-mentioned scne, too. Their interactions, both quite physical and emotional, came across so realistically that I almost felt like a voyeur. Debbie also made me cry when they're at the restaurant and her friend tells her that she came up with enough money to buy the dress and can stand in for her as her matron of honor. Then she and her husband retreat, and Debbie tells Rod she knows her friend is lying, and was doing it just for her benefit. Their litle conversation that ensues just kinda got me right there.

Anyway, I can go on and on for pages to discuss my love for this film, but suffice it to say, it was heartwarming, especially that ending. The first time I saw it, I wasn't so sure I liked the ending, but having seen it a few days ago, it was certainly another tear-inducing moment. P.S.: Of course I don't have to say that Bette Davis and Ernest Borgnine were also magnificent.

reply

One usually thinks of Debbie Reynolds as "cute" and "perky," but in THE CATERED AFFAIR she's just downright beautiful at times.

"Stone-cold sober I find myself absolutely fascinating!"---Katharine Hepburn

reply

Yes!, more movies of her like this!



reply

Debbie STILL looks damned good.

reply

I agree that Rod Taylor was very good in this movie, but affecting an American accent is not the hallmark of great (or good or even mediocre) acting. If that was the case, someone like Peter Sellers would be considered the greatest actor of all time.

What's the big deal about doing an accent? Kate Winslet did a perfect American accent in Titanic and that was hardly a great performance.

reply

[deleted]

Australian actors seem to get American accents.

reply

Great post!

The scenes you mentioned are brilliant, especially the scene in the bedroom with Debbie Reynolds and Rod Taylor. Very emotional scene. They truly played their parts to the fullest. We wish they'd release more Debbie Reynolds movies on DVD like a whole collection for her.

reply

Actually, I think this is Debbie's best film. She was very good as the daughter.

The Divine Genealogy Goddess

reply