War is bad (spoilers)


I saw the Burmese Harp this week for the first time. I thought it was very powerful. Whether or not it was historically accurate was not the point, not for me anyway.

The film show two different groups of Japanese soldiers, the group that surrendered and the group in the mountain that refused to surrender.

The soldiers in the mountain were determined to fight to the death and that is pretty much what happened.

The soldiers that surrendered were a fairly mellow group that liked to sing and seemed interested in rebuilding Japan and returning to their former lives (napping at home, working at the factory, going to the movies, etc). I felt that Ichikawa preferred this mellow group over the vicious group.

It seemed to me that Ichikawa was trying to stress that the old Japan needed to be replaced by a kinder, gentler Japan, that rebuilding and going to work was preferable to going to war. Who knows, maybe I totally missed the point.

reply

This film has a very strong message about the ravages of war and the destruction of young lives. I think that the very moving scene where the British and allied troops surround the village and sing There's no place like home ... and are then joined in the song by the Japanese company signifies that war on foreign soil is nonsensical and that home is more important.

I give my respect to those who have earned it; to everyone else, I'm civil.

reply

I like what you elected to take from the film. It is similar to my perspective. I cannot understand those that are offended by this film because it humanized a handful of Japanese soldiers. This is the same crowd that was infuriated by Letters From Iwo Jima... one of the most haunting and beautiful WW2 movies ever done.

All I can say to these folks is that these are not documentaries ... and the Director did not make this film for your approval. Consider the time and place the film was released and you will well served.

reply

Lemme tell you about war...war's bad, mmmkay?

reply

nice analysis, this was definitely an interesting WW2 movie and a view on war in general





so many movies, so little time

reply