Basic Premise SPOILERS


Would the weight of four extra passengers really hinder the ability of the plane to clear the trees on take-off?

I don't know what kind of plane it was. Looked similar to a DC-3. Specs on that:

Weight:

Empty: 16,865 lbs
Maximum Takeoff: 25,200 lbs

They emptied the plane of every thing they possibly could leaving a barren fuselage.

The four remaining passengers weighed I'm thinking a maximum of 700 lbs. Seems negligible under the circumstances and as such a total dramatic contrivance requiring a little too much suspension of disbelief for my taste.

Liked the movie anyway.

reply

I agree. Those DC3s were pretty tough - some still fly now I think.

reply

I guess they wanted to have a dramatic angle to the story-having the DC 3 just taking off with everybody just would not have cut it-but yes, DC 3s could take more payload than they were ever designed-there's a story of one DC 3 evacuating three times its passenger capacity from China in WWII-this one of course had two engines, but really, just seven or eight people for all that plane! Even the cobbled-up plane of the original Flight of the Phoenix did better than that!

reply

...and, it looked like one of those ethnic jokes (One American, one British, one Pole, one Jew, one Cuban, one Puertorican were in a plane crash...and you get the various reasons why each of them should survive, and the wiliest does so...)

reply

...and, it looked like one of those ethnic jokes (One American, one British, one Pole, one Jew, one Cuban, one Puertorican were in a plane crash...and you get the various reasons why each of them should survive, and the wiliest does so...)

reply

I guess they wanted to have a dramatic angle to the story-having the DC 3 just taking off with everybody just would not have cut it-but yes, DC 3s could take more payload than they were ever designed-there's a story of one DC 3 evacuating three times its passenger capacity from China in WWII-this one of course had two engines, but really, just seven or eight people for all that plane! Even the cobbled-up plane of the original Flight of the Phoenix did better than that!

reply

The problem wasn't taking off. The pilot thought the repaired engine would fail leaving only one engine to get them over the mountains. It should have. It was an early requirement that US passenger planes be able to fly over the Rockies with the loss of one engine.
This was solved in the early days of aviation with three engine planes.

reply