The Ladykillers


I just watched this movie for the first time last night, having already seen the Coen brother's remake, and I don't understand why so many people love this movie. I found the Coen brothers film to be far superior in every way, and this is probably my least favorite of their movies. Not once did I laugh out loud during this movie, maybe a chuckle or two, but nothing more. All this movie did was deepen my respect for the Coen brothers and their ability to make the movie they did considering the source material.

reply

You are a total idiot if you really could not enjoy this classic.Everything about it was and is superior to the remake-watch it again.The remake was misguided in the extreme. Hanks and the old lady were fine but the rest (especially Wayans) were not up to it. The script was the problem, perhaps, rather than the cast.
I first saw the original was I was about 12 and it impressed me so much, it has been one of my all-time favourite comedies.
The Coen brothers do make great movies (Raising Arizona is a fine example) but they made a bad mistake tackling this.
I don't really mind foul lanuage, if it makes some kind of point, but the swearing in this really jarred with me-it just was not necessary. People do swear,of course they do, but not as much as many contemporary movies would have it.

reply

I love this film to death and refuse to watch the remake. I am so grateful I didn't see the remake before I saw this. I walked into the movie with no clue at all where it would go, and as far as I'm concerned that's the only way to approach it.

Some of these terrible remakes have one redeeming feature--they publicize the good original so they can be rediscovered. But the finely crafted plot and pacing of this outstanding caper comedy carries you along so brilliantly, I can't imagine going into the first viewing with an idea of where it will wind up. So, I feel sorry for the people who see the remake first. It's not only a waste of two hours of their lives, but it diminishes the experience of seeing one of the greatest movies ever made.

I don't know what the Coens were thinking when they decided to remake this. But what they did was strip all the charm out of one of the most charming pieces of film ever, and spoil a truly great movie for millions by exposing them to spoilers.

People get banned from this site for spoiling the plot of even a crappy movie, thinking their little comment is worth the price someone who hasn't seen the film pays in reading it. Here the Coen Brothers have spoiled the plot of one of the greatest comedies ever for millions, just because they thought their little exercise in ego was amusing enough to be worth the price. Why haven't we banned them from Hollywood?

reply

i think this is a great film. I haven't seen the remake, but can't imagine it could possibly be as good as this.

reply