time period?


Is Guys and Dolls set in the 40s or 50s?

thanks,
Megan

reply

If you are talking about the book, I have no idea. Check with Amazon. If you are talking about the movie, it can be "guestimated" according to common knowledge and the fashions of the actors.

Let's see what we can figure out.

There was no mention of "war" so it had to be after 1945.

Castro came along in 1959 and closed down Cuba for Americans.

So, we can narrow it to 1946 to 1958.

It is impossible to date Salvation Army garb without an historical record from them.

The clothing styles worn by the "civilian" women is definitely not of the 40s or even early 50s.

The dress syles are closer to 1956 - 1958.

So, it appears that the movie was set exactly the time it was filmed, 1955.

I lived in the mid-west at the time, and we were behind Hollywood as regards to fashions.

reply

" it appears that the movie was set exactly the time it was filmed, 1955."



Interesting theory. But rember that the show was 1950.

reply

On stage, there is a lyric in "Take Back Your Mink" -- "That was late '48, I recall," so the show took place in the "present" of 1950.

In the film, that lyric was changed to remove the reference to 1948, so that it could be in the "present" of 1955.


I've been married to one Marxist and one Fascist, and neither one would take the garbage out.

reply

The stories "Guys and Dolls" is more or less based upon are originally set in the 1930s.

reply

Normally, this show is set somewhere in the '50's, but the recent broadway revival changed the setting to the 1930's, and even included the character of Damon Runyon, who is watching and writing down the action of the show.

reply


Runyon's stories were set in the 1930s, in the Depression, but when the stage musical for 1950 premiere was written and composed, the time, if not the characters, was updated to 1950 (as DryToast mentions, one song has a line about something that happened in "late '48"). That's why there's a slight bit of anachronistic feel about the thing, because those Runyonesque characters didn't exist, or talk, exactly like that in the 1950s, but it still works fine.
.

reply

[deleted]

It looks like the 1950s to me as well.

Its that man again!!

reply

According to the Internet Movie Car Database, most of the cars are 1951 through 1955 models. The confusing thing is that the gamblers are dress and talk like they are from the 30s, due to the Damon Runyan source stories.

reply