MovieChat Forums > Bad Day at Black Rock (1955) Discussion > similarities to "Heat of the Night&...

similarities to "Heat of the Night"


I really liked Bad Day... Apart from the very honest portrayals, direct cinematography and nice exploration of small town moralities with a pleasing pay-off (baddies get it in the end), I can't help noticing a very superficial but interesting similarity with Sidney Poitier and "In the Heat of the Night".

i.e. an individual arrives and leaves by train, encapsulating the drama with a well defined circular start and end point. In each case the unsuspecting individual arrives from the haven of a comfortable and safe extension of civilization (the train) into a nightmarish world of repression where much of the local population are out to get him. The individual manages to transform the lives of some of those he encounters, and in the end triumphs, solves the crime, redeems or incarcerates the locals, and gets back on the train to carry on his normal life (of which we don't really get much of an insight).

reply

At least in the John Ball novel "In the Heat of the Night" but less so in the movie, Virgil Tibbs was also an expert in martial arts just like John J. McCreedy in Bad Day...

reply

McCreedy actually bears more resemblance to Frank McLeod (played by Humphrey Bogart) in Key Largo. Disillusioned former Army officer who arrives in an isolated town searching for relatives of one of the men who served under him. He's just about had it with life in general but finds revival in fighting evil. In McCreedy's case it was Jeff Smith who'd murdered the father of one of his soldiers. In McLeod's case, it was gangster Johnny Rocco who was terrorizing the surviving relatives of one of his men.

reply

I also notice a similarity to "Heat of the night", maybe because both movies, without being "westerns" are exploiting the typical western motif of the foreigner, as foinavon so well explains. Both movies also address the problem of racism. And both depict isolated and morally distorted societies, who are somehow redeemed by the hero. And I love both movies.

reply