MovieChat Forums > An Inspector Calls (1954) Discussion > Inspector Goole not Poole (Major Spoiler...

Inspector Goole not Poole (Major Spoiler)


Calling the Inspector Poole takes away the whole impact of the inspectors name. When you find out that the inspector is only just a ghost, a fiction then Goole is appropriate.

ANYWAY GREAT FILM

reply

I don't think that the inspector was a ghost, he was more of a state of consciousness or a preminition of what was about to happen.

reply

HIS NAME IS INSPECTOR GOOLE!

reply

No it's Not Goole it's POOLE! Get a copy of the film and watch the distinct pronunciation by Alastair Sim. I have a copy and he, the daughter's fiancé, as well as a police officer ALL pronounce the name POOLE.

reply

Get a copy of the play, you idiot, the film was not first.

It's GOOLE. G double-O-L-E.

reply

Just because you feel the need to resort to name-calling, which is very immature and quite rude, doesn't make you right. I have a copy of both the play and the movie and they are different. The name was changed, in the movie, to POOLE. Your nasty, negative posting is unnecessary and doesn't prove any point that you may want to make, except that you are a nasty and uneducated oaf.

reply

What I am trying to get across is that the movie, whilst having changed it, was wrong to change it, and it SHOULD be GOOLE. Otherwise the ending makes less sense than it should.

On the subject of name-calling, calling me a 'nasty and uneducated oaf' is hypocritical. You've just called ME a name.

I am sorry about my previous post, though, I'm not too sure why I posted such a stupid comment ... o_O I was probably just annoyed at nothing in particular ...

reply

I was simply defending myself and was not being at all hypocritical. I did not call you a name by referring to the comment you made as nasty, because it was. I did not call you a name by describing you as an uneducated oaf, which is how you came off by making such a comment. I would accept your apology for the comment if you were to sincerely submit one.

reply

Oh, and on the subject of Poole versus Goole I strongly disagree. Goole, as meant to signify ghoul, is transparently heavy-handed and not in keeping with the benevolent motives and demeanor the Inspector displays. The way in which Alastair Sim depicted the character bore no relation to the evil undead. I think of the Inspector as either an angelic messenger of God or God himself on a mission to teach compassion and offer redemption to the thoughtless members of that family... It's probably why the name was changed for the film.

reply

I don't feel myself that Goole means anything of the evil undead. I think it is merely another name for ghost, spirit, or things of that sort.

And I am sorry for my other post - I seriously do not know why I posted it. Like I have already said, I feel I was probably just ticked off in general, and I had no reason to call you an idiot, or whatever I called you. I hope you accept my apology - seeing as how I'm not too good with apologies anyway and merely tend to repeat my point. Then again, I usually repeat my point in anything I say and do. :/

reply

I accept your apology, however, as far as the Goole vs. Poole issue goes, the encyclopedia describes a ghoul as an evil entity: "It lures unwary travelers into the desert wastes to slay and devour them. The creature also preys on young children, robs graves, and eats the dead." So apparently you're unaware of the definition of a ghoul. I still firmly believe that Alastair Sim's exceptional performance had nothing of the macabre about it and he played the role as a benevolent purveyor of reason and compassion. That sort of caring spirit cannot, by any stretch of the imagination, be considered a ghoul...

reply

That's also how I see the inspector.

reply

funny that in scholl at the mo we are doing an inspector calls and his is called Goole. the whole point of our debate is based on his name and now we can't use the film as an example. what a shame

reply

[deleted]

^Same here. Everyone was like "Poole? Huh?"

reply

you could state the the P in place of G in his surname could mean phantom...i used it in my gcse couse work and got an A

Thunderbirds Aren't Slow

reply

When I studied this for GCSE ever such a long time ago we were told not to mention any specific performance or adaptation and only analyse Priestly's script.

reply

as memort serves he spelles it out for them G O O L E, they would have known it was not gouel-spelt wrong, at least in the book!

Thunderbirds Aren't Slow

reply

[deleted]

I also am studying it for GCSE. Anyone noticed how Goole is an anagram of Ghoul? This is a possble hint from JB Priestly that he was ghost hence Goole/Ghoul.

Also, this can get you a higher grade. Think about the upbringing of Sheila and Eric from Arthur and Sybil. The pair are ifluenced by their parents (mainly Sybil and Sheila) to use their power and authority, best example is Millwards, where Sheila uses her family power to close her and her mothers account unless Eva is sacked. Also sheila is more to blame than you may think, though they all share their piece, if sheila did tell her parents about Erics drinking, then he may have come off the drink, never met Eva and forced his way into her flat getting her pregnant, which means she would never appeal to the womens Charity and using the Birling family name, hence Sybil not having anything to do with her.

Ofcourse, this is just a theory which really boosted my Speaking and Listening grade, and also got me alot of credit by looking into the upbringing rather than just their key role of her death. And remember, they are not murderers, so thats a good point to add, because they did not FORCE her to swallow disinfectant.

Ofcourse they are my theories, use them if you like. Im sure it opens a new angle of viewing everything.

reply

no listen he says my name is inspector goole G double o l e. i remember it like it was yesterday. i learnt all the peoples lines caus i was actually in the stage play bout a month back and i remember it clearly. its inspector goole

reply

Sorry - realise you studied GCSE English - but how can Goole be an ANAGRAM of Ghoul - sorry have to have same letters - Signed 40 yr old with A Level and Degree!!!

reply

I really hope you didn't get a high grade for your GCSE English as you don't even know what an anagram is. The word you are looking for is homophone.

Your spelling, punctuation and grammar in the next couple of paragraphs is dreadful. If children like you are able to pass exams then little wonder that people are complaining that the standard of education has fallen in recent years.

reply

Alright, so the post made a mistake with the word "anagram". Most adults don't know the difference between homophones, alliteration, onomatopoeia etc etc. The spelling, punctuation and grammar aren't exactly "terrible" either, I think that's a little extreme.
And anyway, the poster makes a good point, which will be helpful to me when I do my English Lit. GCSE next year.
But maybe I'm just a "child" passing my easy exams with all my terrible grammar and punctuation mistakes.

reply

Eye teech inglish langwich at Eh levul, an knowhone gets marcs nokked of fer spelng n-e-more. By the way, does anyone know the whereabouts of the TV version with Bernard Hepworth. I have heard that it is superior to the Sim version. I have always felt that Priestley blundered over the character's name; it points too obviously in one direction regarding the Inspector's identity for non-UK audiences. Northern UK audiences, would, I hope, recognise the reference to the grim, soulless, industrial town of Goole on the east coast.

"You've seen these films, haven't you, my man."

reply

i dont have a clue what you just said, but anyway yeah we had the same trouble in school we were like inspector poole wtf?

Me:Emily, im going camping, can i borrow your p.e t-shirt, i need a tent

reply

[deleted]

i'm studying both too! i agree. Malkovich is good but the rest of the cast in OMAM were awful. I haven't seen AICs but think that Priestly is a genius. the novel is very play.

------------------------
www.myspace.com/jacob_u2

reply

Our English lit teacher told us it was changed to Poole from Goole so as to avoid damaging the delicate sensibilities of 1950s Britons. Why? Goole sounds too much like goolies...

'Yes sir; but it does say on the carton that we are an evil dairy.'

reply

Goole is supposed to sound like 'GHOUL' Which is a ghost

"Do I feel lucky? we'll do ya Punk???

Dirty Harry

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I saw the film in my native country tens years ago. The film was dubbed in Russian language, so the name of the inspector was meaningless for the audience. At that time I hadn't known yet an English word. After the Inspector disappeared, I thought that he was God. Performance of Alastair Sim was awesome. I never saw a face so clever as the Inspector's.

reply

As portuguese being my native language, you have made a good point.
I think exactly the same.

reply

Adding my opinion to the many, I think Poole works better. A ghoul is 'an evil spirit', which gives the character inappropriate baggage.

reply