MovieChat Forums > An Inspector Calls (1954) Discussion > If they had all learned something from i...

If they had all learned something from it...


Do you think that had they all learned something from their behaviour, the phone would not have rang at the end saying a young girl had committed suicide? Just a thought.

reply

That thought occurred to me too. The way the Inspector was sitting in the rocking chair next door while they all basically made their decisions on how they were going to deal with the whole issue. The older folks wanted to just laugh it off and forget it, the younger people were more serious and thought it was important to change as a result. And the Inspector seemed to be waiting for something. I too felt that if they'd done things differently, if they'd repented and changed their ways, somehow it would have turned out that Eva Smith hadn't really died, or somehow all this tragedy would not have been necessary. I almost felt as if their skepticism sealed everyone's fate; as if they were making the choice between life and death for Eva, and they chose wrongly.

Flat, drab passion meanders across the screen!

reply

Only Eric and Sheila thought to learn something from it, their parents didn't want to, but even Gerald, young as the siblings, wanted it to be forgotten and written off as some poor joke.

reply

The young adults learned something from it, not the parents.

~~
💕 JimHutton (1934-79) and ElleryQueen 👍

reply

But not Gerald either, and it makes me wonder if it's a ratio and balance thing, if Gerald had been like Eric and Sheila, would that outweigh the parents and Eva would live?

reply

I think that Gerald did learn something from the experience, but his priority was to save the family name. He was also trying to impress Sheila with his knowledge about the "inspector". Also, he was a guest in the house and I think that he was trying to be careful not to snub the parents.

Besides, despite everything they had done, they still had a right to know who this "inspector" was. At that point, they knew that he wasn't a real inspector. They had the right to ask questions about his identity.

Of course, at the VERY end, they got what's coming to them.

~~
💕 JimHutton (1934-79) and ElleryQueen 👍

reply