MovieChat Forums > The High and the Mighty (1954) Discussion > New DVD: deleted scenes restored?

New DVD: deleted scenes restored?


Guys: I'm gonna get a copy this weekend but is the DVD the same as the AMC presentation in July? I think there were scenes missing on AMC.

reply

I got the DVD today, and it looks as if it's the same as the AMC broadcast. I'd mentioned in an earlier message on these threads that I, too, thought there were some missing scenes. Most, as best as my old memory can recall, seem to be at the end as the plane is coming in to the airport. Something's missing, something that added suspense to those scenes. So, tonight I watched the ending as the plane came in for its landing, passing over the lighted runway markers. The plane sets down in the dark, there's a cut to the sleeping little boy, there is no music. So, I pulled out my soundtrack recording and there is about 35 to 40 seconds of music from the original soundtrack music missing from the DVD version, and I'm assuming the movie scenes that music covered. From the music and chorus as the plane sets down, the music builds in volume and orchestra to a finale. After that there's the music as the passengers disembark. There is something missing there. Some of the extras on the DVD said there was missing footage, but that it had been recovered. Apparently, not all was recovered. Maybe it's been so long since this film has been seen, the people restoring it had no idea what they were missing. I think it's great to finally have a copy of the film, but with the AMC broadcast and the DVD version, I still feel it's "missing" something, just can't bring the memories out after all those years as to exactly what, but whatever it was it was important enough to the film, to me at least, to be noticeable.

The ending of this version is almost anti-climactic with whatever it is not there. Or, it could be just my memory fading. I'd still like to know what those 35 seconds of missing soundtrack score covered, before the scenes where the passengers leave the plane.

Also, the chorus singing the theme song is not on the DVD, it's said in one of the commentaries that the chorus was added after release for a few days of viewing so Tiomkin and Washington could qualify for the Best Song Oscar. The lyrics the chorus sings are not the same as those that came with the popular version of the song when it made the hit parade. Those were romantic, the original film chorus was more a tribute to those flying planes.

reply

Thank you, stever. Just got a copy at a store in SFO while on a business trip. I was hoping for better news about missing scenes but thanks for the word.

reply

What I really missed was a shot inside the cabin as the plane landed. How were the passengers reacting? How did they react when the plane landed? I have no idea if that's what is missing, but that's what's needed. After two and a half hours of suspense, the landing was a definite letdown -- as it were!

Corny and melodramatic and dated and imitated as the film may be, it still works, holding a viewer in suspense. There's a level of craftsmanship to it that bespeaks the studio era at its best. The writing is particularly well crafted, going back to Gann's skills as a novelist.

Someone mentioned a soundtrack. Is one available?

reply

The complete soundtrack album, including the rare choral lyrics, is on GEMA 0295.54 .

reply

I'm a little tentative about seeing this now. I had long waited for Batjac(I think that was John Wayne's company's name) to finally release the rights to this film. I haven't seen it for well over 20 years and as with so many things I have hoped that time's passage and my younger age at first viewing had not made a fair film into a great one. I always hope for DVD films to have restored footage that has long been missing (i.e. I keep hoping that the deleted/butchered scenes from Magnificent Ambersons will turn up in someone's attic) and thus restoring the director's original vision...sorry to hear that may not be the case here.

I do not avoid women,Mandrake...But I... I do deny them my essence

reply

The DVD is as I remember TV broadcasts of the movie in the 60's, however, the sound restoration leaves something to be desired on the DVD. May be some deleated or muffled tracks causing confusion. Very noticable is the total obliteration of the "Bang" and "sputtering engine" sound during the FIRE scene. These sounds are plainly heard on an old "taped from TV" copy I have. Actually the sound quality is better on my tape than it is on the DVD!

reply

[deleted]

My feeble old (58-year-old) memory has a distinct recollection that as the plane was (dramatically) making its final approach for landing, it did actually "clip" that 690-foot San Francisco radio broadcasting antenna that John Wayne referred to. Does anyone else recall that as the deleted scene???

Also being a 58-year-old who was very much into the movie music of that (long-ago) day, I always remembered the theme song as just instrumental -- without lyrics.

reply

The plane did not clip the radio tower. In fact, Stack and Wayne have a brief conversation worrying about it, but realize it has to be behind them by then.

However, as I pointed out on two other threads, there is a scene missing from the DVD. It's during Jan Sterling's big scene, as she wipes off her make-up while talking to Paul Kelly. When she's finished, she asks him, "Or do you feel like a -- like a bored priest hiding behind his confessional?" This single sentence lasts only about ten seconds, but it was such a memorable piece of dialogue that its absence is glaring. This line was intact in the film when it was shown on HBO in the early 1980s. I can only assume the print found in Wayne's home for some reason either had this bit cut out, or it was damaged beyond repair, which seems highly unlikely given its brevity and the fact that everything around it was in perfect condition.

I don't recall any other missing scenes, but the DVD is, unfortunately, at least slightly incomplete.

reply