MovieChat Forums > The Glenn Miller Story (1954) Discussion > What was the song they were playing when...

What was the song they were playing when...


...the musician bit his lip and the rehearsal stopped while Miller rearranged. It sounds familiar but I don't know what it is. Help!

reply

Hi Richard

The song was Moonlight Serenade. What an excellent film, and great music.

I don't know if you remember, but you responded to a message board I posted about the jewels Lana Turner wore in Imitation of Life being the same as the ones worn by Doris Day in Pillow Talk. We share an enjoyment of finding these things, and you asked me what eles I'd found.

The facade of the mansion used in Written on the Wind is the same as the facade of the mansion used in High Society;

The staircase and foyer of the mansion in Written on the Wind is the same staircase and foyer as that used for the house Glenn Miller lives in in The Glenn Miller Story (where he dances with his wife for their anniversary);

The house that Millie lives in in the beginning of Old Acquaintance, is the same one used in Three Daughters and sequels; and

The brooch that Ilsa wears when she first visits Rick's Place in Casablance (it looks a bit like a crane with one leg tucked up), is worn by Joan Crawford in Mildred Pierce.

Hope you find these of interest.

Regards

Lee (from Australia)

reply

Lee,

I know Moonlight Searnade and I dont think that was it. But yes I love all that trivia stuff.

The staircase in the Glenn Miller Story is also the same one you'd find in "Tammy and the Bachelor" with Debbie Reynolds. Its also in some B&W Tony Curtis film mid 50s where he played a gambler.

And speaking of staircases, the famous Auntie Mame staircase was in a ton of films:

1948 Bright Leaf Bacall's Southern Plantation
1950 Tea for Two Doris Day's Long Island mansion
1951 Strangers on a Train Leo G Carrol's Washington Mansion
1953 So Big Mansion of possible father in law
1957 Band of Angeles Clark Gable's southern plantation
1957 Spirit of St Louis Hotel lobby before Lindburgh takes off
1958 Auntie Mame Mame's Beekman Pl home, reset many times
1959 A Summer Place Fancy school attended by Sandra Dee
1960 Ocean's Eleven Ilka Chase's fancy mansion
1961 Parrish Karl Malden's mansion
1962 Rome Adventure Rossano Brassi's Rome apartment

Meanwhile at MGM mid 40s theres a double staircase in "Mrs Parkington" also used in "White Cliffs of Dover"

Keep in touch.

Richard

reply

Ilsa's brooch was also worn by Lisa the sister in law in Now, Voyager iin the family party scene when the "new" Charlotte entertains her brothers, wives and an uncle.

reply

It has the words"laughing on the outside, crying on the inside" Forgot the title.

reply

The song was called "I Know Why (And So Do You)"

A band singer does a rendition of it in the 1990 film MEMPHIS BELLE.

"Howdy, Bub"

reply


As Mr. Moody noted, the song is "I Know Why And So Do You." Incidentally, the scene is a fictionalization of what really happened: several years earlier, Miller was musical director for the Ray Noble orchestra, and conceived the "trumpet over saxophones" idea, with high-note specialist Pee Wee Erwin playing the trumpet lead. When Erwin left the band (no lip injury!) they had no trumpet blower who could play those parts. That's when Miller reassigned them to clarinet. So the "clarinet lead" was developed years earlier, and recycled after MIller started his own band. Not nearly as dramatic as having a trumpeter cut his lip, forcing a last-minute rewrite!

Also, it's a fine film, but notice in that scene that the trombones keep going on the soundtrack after the musicians have taken them down...

reply

The song was "Moonlight Serenade". Such a great song and a wonderful movie!

----
"I'll give you the moon, Mary." - George Bailey

reply

[deleted]

The song was "I Know Why and So Do You." After the trumpet player splits his lip Glenn realizes he needs a new lead, and the scene segues into him arranging "Moonlight Serenade" with the clarinet lead.

reply

IMHO, that segues scene - with its continuous play/gradual crescendo of "Moonlight Serenade" from the night-long arranging to the orchestra rehearsal to the actual live performance in front of a large audience - is absolutely magical. Jimmy Stewart does a tremendous job via his facial expressions in dramatizing Glenn Miller's probable inner emotions as he mentally segued from struggling to find "the sound," to thinking he had it, to knowing he had nailed it. Just a wonderful scene that gives me chills every time I see it. Great stuff!

reply

Best scene in the film.

reply

great scene but pure hollywood fiction

reply

The musician didn't bite his lip. His lip split open, which is a hazard when playing trumpets, trombone and the like. I know this because a friend in high school who played the trumpet had this happen a couple of times.

reply

Wasn't it Moonlight Serenade before they added the clarinetist?

reply