MovieChat Forums > The Secret Storm (1954) Discussion > obituary for Judy Lewis (Susan Ames Dunb...

obituary for Judy Lewis (Susan Ames Dunbar Carver)


PHILADELPHIA (AP) — For decades, the identity of Judy Lewis' parents was one of the best-kept secrets in Hollywood.

Not until Lewis acknowledged her story in the 1994 autobiography "Uncommon Knowledge" did the general public know the truth: Lewis was not the adopted daughter of Hollywood starlet Loretta Young but had been conceived out of wedlock by Young and Clark Gable while the two filmed "Call of the Wild" in the 1930s.

Lewis died of cancer Nov. 25 in the Philadelphia suburb of Gladwyne, said Rodger McKinney, owner of the Chadwick & McKinney Funeral Home. Services will be held Saturday. She was 76.

Lewis, of Palm Springs, Calif., was raised in Los Angeles by Young as her adopted daughter. She was an adult when she learned that Young, a devout Roman Catholic, conceived her during an affair with Gable in the 1930s.

"At the time, what Loretta Young did was completely successful," said Leonard Maltin, a film critic and Hollywood historian. "The general public never had any inkling that she had done this. It protected her stardom and her image as a wholesome young woman."

Lewis was born Nov. 6, 1935, in Venice, Calif., and went on to perform on Broadway and television in her own career. She also produced the soap opera "Texas," a spinoff of "Another World." In the 1980s, she earned psychology degrees, advocating for children's rights and counseling teenagers. She later became a psychotherapist in Los Angeles, something she pursued until she was diagnosed with cancer.

In 1994, she wrote "Uncommon Knowledge," acknowledging her parentage publicly for the first time. Her mother was a single Catholic and Gable was married at the time of her birth, and the news would have led to scandal, so she created the story that Lewis was adopted.

"The situation in which they found themselves in 1935 would not have posed such a problem in the Hollywood of today," Lewis wrote in the book.

Lewis wrote that Young kept her sequestered with a nurse for months after her birth and that she was then turned over to an orphanage. When she was 2, Young brought her home as her adopted daughter.

Before her memoir was published, the identity of her parents had long been rumored. Maltin said the truth was never truly public, however, until the memoir, in which Lewis describes her mother telling her the truth in 1966, years after Gable had died.

In the book, Lewis said Young told her then: "'Well, he was your father. ... He was darling. Sweet and very gentle. ... He was married, so when I discovered I was pregnant with you, I was frantic and terrified. It would have ruined both our careers, a scandal like that.'"

Lewis wrote in her book that Young wanted her to keep the secret. She described a heated argument with Young on Mother's Day in 1986, in which Young threatened to sue Lewis if a book came out that revealed the truth about Lewis' parentage.

"'Leave this house. I never want to see you in my house again,'" Young said, Lewis recounted.

"I refused to be dismissed that easily," Lewis wrote. "It all came pouring out — all the years of hurt and abandonment, all the feelings of not belonging, of being an outsider in my own family, years of repressed emotions that couldn't be contained any longer. The floodgates were opened and the words flowed unchecked."

Lewis said she asked Young if she would "ever acknowledge to the world that I am your child, and that Clark Gable is my father?'

"'No. I will never acknowledge what I consider a mortal sin — my mortal sin,'" Young replied, according to Lewis.

Lewis' survivors include her daughter, three half brothers and her partner, Steve Rowland. Another memorial service is being planned for later this month in Los Angeles, McKinney said.

reply

I received a very nice message from Judy Lewis, after writing to her several years ago. It had always been my intention to reply to her reply, perhaps interview her about her years on soap operas (particularly "The Secret Storm") for a website I am planning. I watched Miss Lewis in her final storylines on "Storm," between about 1970 and '73.

I am so sorry to have read here of Miss Lewis' passing. But her candor about her adoption inspired others, like myself, to be honest about my own adoption, maybe even seek out my biological relatives, or at least track down the information.

I have read selections from Miss Lewis' book, which was already out of print when I wrote to her. But she encouraged me to obtain a used or surplus copy of the book, even though she would not receive any compensation from such a sale. I admired her for that, too.

Had I lived in a geographically feasible area, I might well have chosen Miss Lewis as my own therapist.

This is such sad news, even though I realize illness and death are parts of life.

If any of Miss Lewis' survivors read my post here, please feel free to contact me. You certainly have my condolences, and Judy Lewis was a good human being.

reply

I can vouch for a fact that Ms. Lewis was indeed very nice. I ran into her one day at a drug store in Los Angeles. I was glancing at a soap magazine, and this beautiful older woman happened to mention that she had once been on a soap. I said I was a soap historian and asked which one. She mentioned "Secret Storm". I said I had never watched about it, but knew it was about the Ames family. She mentioned she had played Susan. I asked, "Are you Judy Lewis?", rather stunned, and she smiled in delight and admitted she was. I mentioned I had read her book and she was even more pleased, if humble, about her work not going unrecognized. Unlike the book by another "Secret Storm" cast member, Judy's book was most respectful of her family legacy. Before I left the store, I turned around and said, "You were also Laura's mother on "GH"....."I sure was!", she said, laughing. I'll never forget that moment.

reply