MovieChat Forums > Stalag 17 Discussion > i absolutly love this movie

i absolutly love this movie


it makes me happy. thought id share it.

reply

I can watch it anytime!

reply

[deleted]

Amen! I know It's a cliche' but they don't make 'em like they used to!


reply

[deleted]



I love the whole betty white running gag, so awsome, i too love this movie. now i wish i could find it on DvD or VhS



"His mercies are new every morning"Lamentations 3:22-23
I WAS IN THE POOL, I WAS IN THE POOL

reply

I think you mean Betty Grable. Betty White was on the Golden Girls!

I think Stalag is one of Wilder's most underrated movies, in a way. Seems that most film historian snobs don't give it the time of day, for whatever reason. Maybe it plays as "too patriotic" for them or some crapola. Many other intelligencia seem to have a problem with the humor, as if it's inappropriate, but I've always thought the movie had a great balance of pathos/comedy/mystery. Lastly, Wilder himself never seemed all that crazy about the movie. All of this may account for it's lack of appreication today. I think it deserves much more.

One of the things that makes Stalag 17 great is it's authenticity. It was written & acted largely by men who had served in World War II. The conditions in the camp are appropriately deprived (even depraved on occassion, i.e., The Animal!) and filthy. It was also made close enough to the war to ring true with equipment and lingo. On top of it all, it's got one hell of a great payoff.

reply

After watching this film I did not realize how much of a genius Billy Wilder is. I've seen Some Like it Hot, Sunset Blvd, The Apartment, The Seven Year Itch, maybe some others...and this. After seeing this movie, I was blown away...what a masterpiece. They don't make them like they used to. Like it was said in the beginning of the movie, where it was all like this is the first you have ever seen a prison at a POW camp...or whatever (I know I am wayyy off.) Now today, people just COPY COPY COPY! This movie is the best of the best.

reply

so do I ... but I have to ask a question to the general readers here...why is it that after the sixties or seventies you never heard a word about the japanese prison camps? were not the horrible things the japanese did back then equal or go beyond the germans? I apologize as I know this is a post on Stalag 17 which is one of my favorite movies, but all the historical stuff that posters (is that the correct term?) seem to know, I never hear a word about the atrocities done by the japanese during this war...

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, I love this film - I have loved every Billy Wilder film i've seen. Plus I have a great like for films and tv shows set in POW camps. Not quite sure why, being a 20yr old gal from Oz. but I do. I love this, the Great Escape, Hogan's Heroes, as well as Changi - which was about Australians in a Japanese POW camp. A fantastic series.
William Holden was so great in this - i just heard he only got to say thanks for his Oscar before the music cut him off - which is one of the reasons its an open time show.

"Everything in this room is eatable. Even I'm eatable. But that’s called cannibalism."

reply

Watch Lean's 'Bridge on the River Kwai', as it deals with that theme.

"What do you want me to do, draw a picture? Spell it out!"

reply

[deleted]

Definitely worth owning, if you can still find it.

reply

[deleted]

You know why this movie is so great?

There's no stupid love story to slow it down. (That's what hurts "The Caine Mutiny," IMO --- the boring romantic subplot).

And I'll tell you another great movie unencumbered by a love story --- "12 Angry Men."

reply

Me, too.

reply

It's a good movie, but I liked "The Great Escape" a lot more.

reply

[deleted]

I like Stalag 17 and The Great Escape just about equally. What I love about the latter is the comprehensive way it looks at digging escape tunnels, and all the challenges involved. And of course, nothing quite tops that thrilling (and iconic) finale with McQueen on his bike.

Having said that, Sefton's unmasking of the real stoolie in Stalag 17 makes for a very satisfying (and, in its own way, exciting) conclusion. I also feel Stalag 17 presents a grittier and more realistic picture of POW life. Their uniforms actually look like they've been worn - and consequently, not washed - for a very long time.

http://bp0.blogger.com/_WkKZJVG5wTk/RdV4BBctuUI/AAAAAAAAHEQ/pevwsIw-nT 8/s1600-h/Stalag-17_93.jpg

Even though conditions would have been better for the officers in The Great Escape, some of them look so well-groomed it's hard to believe they're in a camp at all - for example, James Garner (with his spotless uniform and gleaming white turtleneck) and John Leyton (with his perfectly styled hair and gleaming white teeth) look like they're all set for their GQ photo shoots.

http://www.imdb.com/media/rm3794175232/tt0057115

http://www.johnleytonofficial.com/media/history/great_escape_6.jpg

But I'm crazy about both films and, needless to say, I have copies of both in my DVD collection.

reply

I just watched it for the first time last night and loved it.

reply

me too I loved with A man escaped

My TOP 200 Movies -http://www.imdb.com/list/iFa7p7uwsr8/

reply

absolutely true
you could watch stalag 17 and bridge on the river kwai and the great escape
back to back to back and never be bored for one second

reply

amen to that. all of those films are brilliant.
Kwai is nothing short of breathtaking as is the great escape.
stalag 17 was MASH long before there was MASH
when it comes to war movies these are all in a class
by themselves and will never ever grow old.

reply