MovieChat Forums > Peter Pan (1953) Discussion > Wonderful movie. As usual, classics hold...

Wonderful movie. As usual, classics hold up while the modern films don't


Recently going through some of the Disney films that I never viewed or had forgotten, I'm amazed at how poor the modern ones are. Tarzan, Mulan, Hercules, Princess and the Frog, these are all pretty disappointing, some almost terrible.

Then I come to a true classic like this, and I'm amazed at how good it is.

Wonderful theme, the balance that must be struck between practicality and imagination. You don't want to become a Captain Hook, like the family's father is in danger of being, but you can't be just a flighty Peter Pan either.

Great tale about the importance of motherhood too, the implication being that the "Lost Boys" are fated to become thugs and thieves, like the pirate crew (what we would consider a gang today) without a stable family life and parental involvement.

Wendy's brothers have almost forgotten what a mother is, that role being taken on by Wendy herself and the family dog, whereas both parents should be more involved.

Wendy has a great arc, at first being the champion of fantasy, but then, when fantasy runs amok, becoming the voice of practicality -- the voice of her father, unexpectedly.

And Tinkerbell is a completely delightful character precisely because she's not just some angel, but a feisty, jealous, but also good-hearted and self-sacrificing young woman. And of course, very, very pretty.

That too contributes to Wendy's arc -- for at first, she's the one who's the target of jealousy (from Tinkerbell), but then she feels jealous herself (because of Tiger Lily).

Really a splendid movie, and with some wonderful songs.

The one criticism? Hook is too pathetic a villain and too easily dispatched. One ends up feeling sorry for him. Also, some of the humour is too forced.

reply

I agree that a lot of the newer Disney films don't hold up to classics like Peter Pan. I just couldn't be entertained by Tarzan, nor The Hunchback of Notre Dame (though I love the soundtrack), and those movies were very popular during my childhood. At the same time, some of the older movies lag a bit too (The Rescuers Down Under comes to mind...). Peter Pan is one of my favorites.

"I must express myself." - Delia Deetz

reply

I couldn't agree more with your comments. If you thought "Peter Pan" was a great animated film, I suggest you check out Disney's "Pinocchio.." from 1940; it's even better, an absolute masterpiece..

"IMdB; where 14 year olds can act like jaded 40 year old critics...'

reply

Wonderful theme, the balance that must be struck between practicality and imagination. You don't want to become a Captain Hook, like the family's father is in danger of being, but you can't be just a flighty Peter Pan either.

Great tale about the importance of motherhood too, the implication being that the "Lost Boys" are fated to become thugs and thieves, like the pirate crew (what we would consider a gang today) without a stable family life and parental involvement.

Wendy's brothers have almost forgotten what a mother is, that role being taken on by Wendy herself and the family dog, whereas both parents should be more involved.

Wendy has a great arc, at first being the champion of fantasy, but then, when fantasy runs amok, becoming the voice of practicality -- the voice of her father, unexpectedly.

Very good points. This film flies in the face of the pro-selfishness or identity-politics-baiting themes that pervade modern animation. It's a true classic and refreshingly untimely (which actually makes it even more relevant today).

reply

[deleted]