MovieChat Forums > Call Me Madam Discussion > The new DVD is a beauty!

The new DVD is a beauty!


My own long-awaited copy of the newly-released DVD arrived today and I'm happy to report that the video transfer looks and sounds near-perfect. Leon Shamroy's glowing Technicolor cinematography, along with Irene Sharaff's not-at-all-dated costumes, Robert Alton's lively choreography, John DeCuir's handsome production design, and Alfred Newman's Oscar-winning supervision of Irving Berlin's ultra-melodious score all wonderfully complement the ensemble playing of a terrific cast. There aren't a lot of extras on this disc, the major one being a full-length commentary by "Musical Film Scholar" Miles Kreuger (which I haven't listened to yet), but for a bargain price (just over $10.00!) this is one terrific value for anyone who enjoys Hollywood movie musicals at their bightest and brassiest.

reply

I was waiting for this to come out on video and later on DVD for years and years. I grabbed it at once when i saw it online, and since this movie is rarely shown in Germany, and has been cut in its dreadful dubbed version, this is the real thing, I love it. Ethel Merman is hilarious.

reply

I recently bought a copy of the DVD via Amazon and although they said it was for Region 1 only, (I live in Region 2) I thought I'd try it. If it didn't work, too bad. However, it did work on my computer - but nearly banjaxed my machine as it took a lot of persuading to go back to playing Region 2 DVDs again! Why do they make DVDs for different regions? To quote a character from "Annie" - "It ain't fair"!

reply

Perhaps I got a bad copy, but I found the quality of the DVD "Call Me Madam" to be decidedly sub par. The images were blurry, the color variable and the sound often very tinny and without much depth. The movie itself is a marvelous showcase for all involved and it deserves a better transfer.

reply

I must reluctantly agree. The transfer was a big disapointment. With the ladies wearing blotchy orange lipstick, you would have thought the technicians at Fox Home Video would have realized something was not quite right with the print they were using. The poor color transfer sadly detracts from several of the dramatic scenes, including the touching farewell between O'Connor and Vera-Ellen in the wine cellar. This wonderful musical is more visually pleasing if you can catch it on the Fox Movie Channel.

reply

I don't find the transfer as disappointing as some viewers, but I am upset that the first two notes of music are missing from the credit titles - how could Fox have been so sloppy? No-one else seems to have noticed, however - I haven't seen one review or comment which has mentioned this!

reply

I've watched my copy of this DVD more than once and am surprised at the complaints of a couple of posters here. Mine is about as good as one could hope for, considering the age of the film, the condition of the source material, and the probable fact that the Fox Home Video technicians did not lavish meticulous care on its transfer (since the projected price was, let's face it, bargain basement). My memory of seeing it in a downtown Boston, Massachusetts, theater during its first-run release is still amazingly vivid, and I recall that the wine cellar scene was, for the tastes of today's audiences, seemingly underlit, but on my copy of the DVD I've got no complaint at all about the transfer.

It's entirely possible that some hastily manufactured copies are not up to snuff, and I know I'd return one if I found it inferior, as I did a DVD of "The World of Henry Orient" which had absolutely abominable audio. I got a refund on that one, since I heard (by the time I'd finally acquired my own copy), that the soundtrack had been horribly muddled by the video manufacturer.

reply

Mine is lovely, the transfer is as perfect as I could ask for.

The only dissapointing thing was the commentary.

reply

Why did you find the commentary disappointing, Dejajeva? I found it interesting and comprehensive. A very good friend was nice enough to loan me a copy, but I was surprised that it wasn't in letterbox format.

The picture quality is vivid and the entire look of the film is beautiful.

Give thanks for a little and you will find a lot.

reply

CALL ME MADAM has the best commentary of a "film historian" of any DVD I've ever heard!! This man, Miles Krueger, is a musical expert and he knows his business. (And he has a pleasant, professional delivery an added bonus.) I appreciate hearing someone who has the nerve to be a commentator on a DVD actually go to the trouble and know about the history of the production, the character's it's based on, how the film differs from the play, information on the cast, etc. I have heard plenty of commentaries where the person seemed to be talking off the top of their head and clearly knew very little about the production or it's players!

reply

"I was surprised that it wasn't in letterbox format."

CALL ME MADAM wasn't filmed in a widescreen process.

"I don't use a pen: I write with a goose quill dipped in venom!"---W. Lydecker

reply