MovieChat Forums > My Cousin Rachel (1954) Discussion > Olivia's ambiguous 'Rachel' praised by D...

Olivia's ambiguous 'Rachel' praised by Dennis Grunes...


"Olivia de Havilland’s cunning performance as Rachel Sangalletti tests the limits of one’s openness to a certain kind of acting. Ingeniously, and with surgical skill, de Havilland plays her scenes so we see how evil Rachel may be and how evil she may not be, except in the eyes of impulsive young Philip Ashley, who, out to prove her the murderer of his cousin Ambrose, whose death has left him rich, himself succumbs to her charms. But is Rachel only after the Ashley wealth she presumed would be hers?

De Havilland has a field day with this ambiguous role, playing nothing, as it were, and playing it brilliantly."

And to think: George Cukor once stated that Olivia "had no mystery" and this was one of the reasons he left the project after hoping to coax Garbo out of retirement and then going after Vivien Leigh. Olivia said she treasured Cukor's comment when, after seeing the film, he changed his mind and called Olivia to congratulate her on her "brilliant" performance.

Personally, I think Garbo would have been all wrong for the role at 47. She turned it down at the last moment, afraid to make another film.


"Somewhere along the line, the world has lost all of its standards and all of its taste."

reply

I'm noting comments, having seen this film on tv today for the first time in many years. I had forgotten how good it is.

Your comments are very interesting. Cukor didn't think deHavilland had any mystery. How interesting.

I also think Garbo would've been wrong for the film (her age doesn't matter, unless she looked old). But Vivien Leigh would've been very good. DeHavilland was perfect, however.

Another good DeHavilland film...The Heiress. I still get chills at what I think is her last line in the film. "Yes, I can be very cruel. I have been taught by masters."

reply

"Cukor didn't think deHavilland had any mystery."
Well, I guess he was very wrong.

I always thought she was a very good, multi-faceted actress, who could play shy and plain (The Heiress), dark, devious and mysterious (Rachel) or just plain sexy (Robin Hood, Elizabeth and Essex, Captain Blood).

Jessica Rabbit
"I'm not bad. I'm just drawn that way."

reply

Olivia was perfection. She was multifaceted versatile actress. One of the most talented off all time in my opinion.

reply

Twelve years later, Olivia de Havilland played the same sort of role in "Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte."

reply

The late Dame Olivia certainly did have mystery in this one. It's time for me to give this a rewatch.

reply