MovieChat Forums > Jack and the Beanstalk (1952) Discussion > Why hasn't Warner Archives released this...

Why hasn't Warner Archives released this movie?


They issued its companion film, Abbott and Costello Meet Captain Kidd, well over a year ago, in a nicely restored print. So why not Jack and the Beanstalk?

Both films were released by Warner Bros. in 1952, each made by a production company owned by one of the duo (Bud owned Captain Kidd and Lou owned Jack). Warner Archives has also issued the boys' 1942 MGM film Rio Rita (and Warner earlier released their other two MGM films on standard DVD), so why not the one remaining A&C film the studio owns, or at least is as free to release as anyone else?

Incidentally, TCM runs an excellent print of this film, very good color.

reply

hobnob,go on Amazon,a digitally remastered version of this,and Africa Screams (which is now in colour)are available at great prices on region 1 and 2.

reply

Thanks, buddyboy28. I already own a copy of Jack, which is in the public domain. But my feeling is that, since Warner has access to the original print, a DVD from them would be of the best quality, as is the case with Captain Kidd.

I know of the double-feature DVD you mention. I have a fair copy of Africa Screams, but under no circumstances will I ever, ever, ever buy a colorized -- not "color" (or "colour"!) -- version of a b&w movie. Aside from vandalizing and distorting the actual look and feel of a film, colorization is fake, inaccurate, poorly executed, spotty and made up -- not in the remotest way an accurate rendering of what the picture would have looked like had it in fact been filmed in genuine, honest, actual, true color. Hence, the correct term "colorized", denoting a process designed to cheat the viewer and demean the film. It's not "color", which is something real.

But thank you for trying! Much appreciated. Take care.

reply

No problem but I should point out that this digitally remastered Africa Screams has colour and black and white options.Might be worth checking out.I'm going to get it myself,my Africa Screams is terrible quality.

reply

Yes, with DVD you can now "toggle" the picture so that you can see either b&w or color.

My problem is that, one, buying such a disc encourages the process of colorization, which I don't want to do; and two, in order to be able to colorize a film they have to "wash out" the original print, so to speak -- lighten it and reduce the contrasts in order to smear on their fake color -- so that the b&w original on such discs isn't as sharp as it should be. I own two colorized movies that can be toggled to b&w, and the only reason I bought them is because the prints used were complete, vs. the earlier, pure b&w DVDs, which cut portions of the opening and closing credits. But that was a special case.

Nevertheless, when you get the DVD I'd appreciate hearing how both films look -- if you wouldn't mind posting a quick note about them. Thanks!

reply