MovieChat Forums > The Crimson Pirate (1952) Discussion > WB should make a new version

WB should make a new version


after the sucses of POTC i think that WB should make a new version of the crimson pirate.
who do you think should play in the new version?

reply

I guess the pause between the original posters date (Sep 2004) and my reply (April 2005) is enough of an answer: There is no contemporary actor who could replace Burt Lancaster even remotely as lead actor in a remake.

A remake of "Crimson Pirate" would be as pointless as the lousy flopped remake of the "Flight Of The Phoenix": You can't beat a classic!

reply

I agree.
This movie is a classic that needs no remakes. "Pirates Of The Caribbean" makes one nice homage to the movie when Sparrow and Turner walk under water with a boat on top of their heads.

reply

I agree too..
The magic of the crimson pirate can never be the same if a remake was made. And we must relyya hope that it never will be a new one. Or maybe if I succes as a director in the future and will be able to make it=)

reply

In short.....you're ever so right!!!
Forgot the underwater gig?
Got's to git now, later!

reply

I agree 100%
There is no one that can replace Burt Lancester.....

reply

Or Nick Cravat

reply

[deleted]

I agree that no contemporary actor could replace Burt Lancaster in this movie. Burt Lancaster was a trained gymnast and acrobate before he was an actor. During the '30's he was a high wire and trapezee artist with his friend and frequent co-star Nick Cravat. They grew up together in NYC. My dad knew and worked with them in a travelling carnival for a few years during the depression. When the movie was first broadcast on tv my dad told me stories of their times then. They needed no stunt doubles for this movie!

reply

Back around 1978 or so, WB announced that Burt Lancaster had signed to do a sequel, "Jolly Roger: Son of the Crimson Pirate", but nothing ever materialized. Anyone know why?

reply

Why did a sequel never materialize? The typical vagueries of the Hollywood system I would say and the difficulties of dealing with star egos. There are some very amusing pages in George MacDonald Fraser's book 'The Light's On At Signpost' that deals with his experiences trying to create a sequel to 'The Crimson Pirate'. Fraser would have been the perfect screenwriter for the job but it seems that Lancaster and his production company partners just couldn't settle on a story.

reply

I just acquired "Light's" and it is a brilliant, if curmugeonly, piece of work. I am a great fan of GMF, and I agree, that he (no doubt drawing heavily on his own "Pyrates") would have done the job!

reply

A UK release of Crimson Pirate would be nice, as i too think Pirates of the Carribean has made lots of nods to its heritage and i remake would probably be a shambles.

reply

(Visions of the remake of 'The Music Man') NOooooooooo!

reply

A remake of "The Crimson Pirate" would be an insult to the original, everyone who was involved in the original and to general audiences.

reply

doint even go there crimson is classic leave it alone,we doint need a remake..

reply

no, no remake.. but potc is kinda like this.. i mean the story is based on this movie and also some of the scenes are the same

reply

No way can there be a remake!! HOWEVER, it would great to see a fully restored, THX-ed version re-released to theatres!!! I love this movie!!

I can remember my grandfather laughing like crazy during the underwater scene. He died a week later and that is what I remember best.

reply

None, I do not like remakes and it's be impossible to find a decent actor to fill Torin's shoes as Humble Bellows.

reply

No way. I like the way this film can be preserved as a highlight in older cinema, a remake just wouldnt go down well, and after the POTC trilogy and whatever other piratey spin-offs we might get, people might be sick of the genre.

It's a shame they dont push and play this film more often on television. I've yet to find it in HMV so a digitally restored DVD release would be more than a welcome addition to my collection.

reply

I'm sorry but I dont really underestand this american love for remakes. If movie is good then there's no need for "new" version. It stays great no matter when it was filmed.


Yossi

reply

Well, I'm American, and I have no love for remakes, either. A classic should be left alone!

reply

We all know the "remakes" Hollywood comes up these days, it will fail badly, so leave it out please. Crimson Pirate will never be as good as the 1952 Crimson Pirate, period.
No matter whos directing, writing, or acting it.
_____________________
Any last words ?
Shut the *beep* up
-Mutant Chronicles-

reply

Who in the world would they get to replace "Lang and Cravat" as they were billed in their circus days? Even if you could find the acrobats, they wouldn't have the charm or the acting chops of the originals. They'd probably have to use CGI characters, and woudln't *that* be the worst idea in history?

reply

Remakes should be illegal! I'm sick of the butchering of classic movies with pc rewrites, poor casting and cgi special effects.

Remember Rabbit Ears with tin foil?

reply