Of great historical value!


Although you don't see the burning bodies, etc., the movie describes accurately the struggle of American tank crews in standard-issue M4 Sherman tanks to go head to head with better equipped German armor in the early years of WW II. It then describes the relief felt when new Shermans with better armor and guns were delivered in 1944, late in the war but never too soon for the American tank crews. The movie ends with the triumphant introduction of the M26 Pershing heavy tank, a great success -- but ironically, not in WWII but rather in the Korean War, as WWII ended before the Pershing could see much service. Few American military films deal with tanks except in a generic way. This may be the sole American film to deal honesty with the tanks, if not with the terror of warfare.

reply

Of great historical value unless you want the truth. Two errors and I will leave it at that.

It never snows in Europe.

M26 not introduced until 1945. The Sherman had a 75 or 76 gun.

reply

alphboo said:
"It never snows in Europe."


What on Earth are you talking about? It snows frequently in Europe. Every European country gets snow at least occasionally. A couple years ago, even Athens, Greece, was covered in snow and ice. Specifically in World War II in Europe, the Battle of the Bulge was marked by lots of fighting in snow, because it happened in December and January.


reply

alphboo was being facetious.He obviously was referring to the lack of winter scenes in the movie.

reply

Old thread but I finally watched this last night. It was interesting and the early tank battle did have some realistic touches. Panther being a tough nut from the front but pretty lightly protected on the sides. Use of WP rounds to blind the Panther.

There was a lot of hokey stuff too. The M26 (err..."90") being brought to the front and handed over to an M4 crew with no training, then...straight into battle...lol.



It was great to see those Shermans driven hard. They moved pretty well.

reply