MovieChat Forums > The River (1951) Discussion > One of my favorite cuts in the movies

One of my favorite cuts in the movies


A dissolve, actually: when Mr. John is speaking about how actually it's fortunate that "a child died as a child" and then in the middle of his pontificating, we dissolve to Harriet sitting at the table, in grief and misery. To me it underscores the phoniness of what the old man was saying. All his pseudo-wisdom means nothing to the heartbroken young girl who's just lost her brother. Later, it's Captain John who's able to comfort her.

I wonder if this is the effect Renoir was going for or if anyone else took it the same way. The rest of the film is so classically restrained that this dissolve had quite an unsettling effect, at least to me, almost as if it was an avant-garde moment. I liked it.

reply

I think he was a strange old guy but something made you listen when he talked as there was an intensity about him. I didn't really understand why he said what he said about the child dying but then I didn't understand an earlier comment he made to his daughter, when she said she's yet to find where she will fit in, and he said "Perhaps it's best that you hadn't been born." Her reaction? "Well I am born." said in such a placid fashion that it beggared belief. I think most of us would be mortified if our dad said that to us! Strange. I will definitely have to watch it again. I think Renoir just included all the things that happen in real life - the good, the bad and the unexpected. I think that is why this film drew me in, it did seem very naturalistic at times.

reply