Read the book?


Not that I have any intention of watching the movie rather than reading the book I was interested if any of you have read the book.

reply

I am currently reading the book. It is an interesting book. However, the book seems plotless and too confusing by the fifth chapter.

reply

Yes. Over the years for some unknown reason I have managed to collect 10 different versions of it, including a copy from 1896. I also have 3 comic book versions. There is version of the comic which was releasd with the movie: Motion Picture Comics # 105,"The Red Badge of Courage",July 1951 with a picture of Audie Nurphey on the cover. Unfortunately I haven't been able to afford it. I believe a copy recently sold for around $1000US. I'm not sure how true it is though.

If I remember correctly the story of Henry Fleming doesn't end with the Red Badge of Courage. Crane wrote about Henry in a short story (all 4 pages) in 1896. The story is called 'The Veteran' and can be found it in a book titled "The Little Regiment" and other Civil War Stories. A version of Red Badge of Courage I purchased recently has it added at the end of the book.

Cheers,

Barry

reply

I finished reading it recently. I can't imangine how Huston adapted it. It's such an internal story.

I'm the king of the castle
You're the dirty rascal
Crash into me..

-The Dave Matthews Band

reply

he does a good job.



The circulation of confidence is better than the circulation of money.-James Madison

reply

Yeah, I've read the book, and I'd like to see this movie. I wish it'd be broadcast on TCM but I'm not holding my breath for it.

Is this a piece of your brain?
http://www.scribd.com/doc/26399550

reply

Dont wanna spoil the movie, but... it's courious how come Henry never confess he ran in the book :)

reply

Shame, what else?

In "The Veteran" (a short story sequel to RBoC, Henry does eventually confess in 1896).

🇺🇸 Liberty and Union, Now and Forever, One and Inseparable. 🇺🇸

reply

OMG, O.M.-freakin'-G, I hated that book so much that I almost commited suicide to get out of reading it! lol


Because of the book, I avoided watching the movie for years, but finally saw it and LOVED it!
"Johnny Tremain," was great though!
Remember having to read that one and "Light in the Forest?"
Now you have me reminiscing back to 6th grade. lol


addie

reply

Holy Cow, I'm surprised at the negative comments about the book. I read this and loved it. I thought this was an easy read, I zipped right through it in an afternoon, it's short. This book used to be one that was read in school(Jr High)I came her looking for information about the film as I've never seen it, it will now be on my list of films to see.

"Insanity runs in my family. It practically gallops."

reply

Why must I read the book? We're talking about a movie here not a book. Two different mediums altogether.The book doesn't have brilliant monochrome cinematography or a splendid score or dynamic performances. Does it ???


Windage and elevation my friend - windage and elevation.

reply

It doesn't have those things, any more than any other book has. It's only among the greatest English language books ever written about war, that's all.


"The value of an idea has nothing to do with the honesty of the man expressing it."--Oscar Wilde

reply

[deleted]