MovieChat Forums > The Man with a Cloak (1952) Discussion > Great cast. starts slow. gets better.

Great cast. starts slow. gets better.


great cast... Stanwyck, Cotton, Backus, Caron. Markle only directed FOUR films, and was given mostly TV projects, acc to IMDB. there ARE some clever lines, but its a period piece, so it had a strike against it before it started. Stanwyck even SINGS a song (kind of). Gets better as it goes along. stick around to the end.
ksf-2



reply

I liked it pretty well. Stanwyck fans have to see it because it contains one of her best moments: She laughs contemptuously at Joe De Santis just before he shuts her up with a kiss.


...Justin

reply

How is being a period piece "a strike against it"?

reply

I enjoyed it, tremendously. It has a "TV-feel" to it, but the dialogue sparkles, as does the cast. Stanwyck is quite one-dimensional but her icy coolness is just what the part demands. Cotten could not be improved upon, IMHO. Again: very enjoyable.

reply

So glad I stuck with it! I was just thinking this morning there were a lot of Stanwyck movies I didn't know so I turned it on. It was so different, seemingly formulaic, like it was pieced together from stories of the era and then the payoff in the end. The mystery was almost a red herring. Full of great performances in timeless characters. I specially liked Jim Backus. What fun!

reply

Starts slow and gets better, that's just right. At one point I found myself thinking all it needed was Orson Welles.

You've got me?! Who's got you?!

reply

The screenplay is by Frank Fenton, who also did "Walk Softly, Stranger", another movie with some fantastic dialogue. He also wrote a couple of well-received books that are impossible to find.

reply