MovieChat Forums > Fröken Julie (1951) Discussion > Reminds me of Hitchcock's Rebecca

Reminds me of Hitchcock's Rebecca


Anyone else? It's got that Jane Eyre, mad woman in the attic thing going for it. In this case it's not two rivals for the same man's affection but mother and daughter which puts a new spin on it. Deals nicely with fate and has a we-are-who-we-are attitude to class and gender. For me, very enjoyable. Ends quite abruptly but it's probably better that way rather than devolving further into melodrama.

reply

I can see it. Very different films under the hood, I think, but I can see it. On the surface I think there's enough justification for that association. Although probably only on the surface. The battle of the sexes/battle of the classes core of Strindberg/Sjöberg's work is really not there in Hitchcock's film (if we can call it Hitchcock's film -- it's probably more accurate to call it O. Selznick's film, despite Hitchcock's virtuoso direction). "Rebecca" lacks the thematic foundation of the later film. For all its masterful use of the elements of mood, tone, and atmosphere, there's not a lot of depth in "Rebecca" beneath the surface. That's typical of American cinema, of course, versus the much more thematically profound cinema produced in Europe. I think "Rebecca" calls to mind, if anything, Hitchcock's themes from his later film, "Vertigo", regarding the past as a living entity that we keep buried inside of us, tormenting us with its dreadful control over our lives, and forcing us to ultimately resign ourselves to its will. For this reason, I always said "Rebecca" reminded me vaguely of many of the films of Alain Resnais, although obviously it doesn't go anywhere near into the same level of depth as a film like "Last Year at Marienbad". I also remember thinking during "Rebecca" something like, "If Bergman made a Hollywood film…". I'm not sure how much I still feel that way, retrospectively, but the suffering of the characters in the film under the hand of a higher power that may only exist in their own minds certainly warrants at least some minor comparisons to Bergman. Naturally, it's a small step from Bergman to Strindberg, and from Strindberg to Sjöberg. So yeah, I can see why you'd say that.

reply