Why not in widescreen?


Anyone know?

reply

Because before 1953, almost all films were shot in a "Full Screen"/4:3 (approx) aspect ratio. It wasn't until the advent of the Richard Burton film 'THE ROBE' (1953) that widescreen processes began to be widely used. THE ROBE was the first movie filmed in CinemaScope (about 2.55:1) and if you ever get a chance, it's a movie worth seeing for the way in which the director is obviously gleefully showing off the 'new' widescreen format.

I'm unsure of the films pre-1953 that were filmed in widescreen. I know the 1927 silent 'NAPOLEON' reverts to a primitive widescreen process at the finale, and was achieved by running three cameras simultaneously. It's an interesting effect.

Hope this answers your concerns!!

Regards

Glumpy

reply

Thats interesting, I always figured the folks who transphered the film to DVD were too lazy to do so in widescreen.

reply

anyone seen The Desert Rats?? Thats another good Rommel movie.

reply

Glumpy's right. No widescreen until '53 - Hollywood's grab to stop people from sitting home watching their new 'toy' called television.

reply

Another way to determine whether it's widescreen is that, in this case, there's no credit for CinemaScope (Fox's later w/s process). You can also simply tell that this isn't a widescreen movie being run "full screen" because none of the actors speaks from off-screen, there's no panning-and-scanning, and so on.

There were a few widescreen films made before 1953. Fox Film Corporation (one of the predecessors of 20th Century-Fox) used a process called "Grandeur" for a couple of films in 1930, notably The Big Trail with a young John Wayne. But widescreen films weren't a novelty that people cared for and theaters didn't want to invest in changing the size of their screens to accommodate the wider image, so the idea died off until desperation over the threat of TV moved Fox and other companies to move to widescreen processes in the early 50s, which the equally strapped theaters were now happy to accept.

The process Fox later called CinemaScope was actually developed over thirty years earlier, but dusted off as something "new" in 1953.

reply

A filmography of 11 movies from 1929 to 1931 which were filmed in
widescreen or utilized some widescreen shots. Unfortunately most
are either lost or only a fullscreen version survives.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_widescreen_feature_filmography

reply

The Big Trail is one of my favourites of the early widescreen trailblazers. The two reasons it didn't take off, and had to be scrapped until a much less expensive solution was formed in the 50's, were that it was extremely expensive for theatres to be renovated in order to show these films, and it was done just on the cusp of the Great Depression. Since filming this way was extremely expensive, the new financial circumstances meant the process had to be scrapped. There's a lot about this in the documentary extras on the 2-disc set of The Big Trail. A neat thing about that release is that it has both versions, though since I loved the 70mm version so much, I have no wish to see the full screen rendition.

reply