MovieChat Forums > The Browning Version (1951) Discussion > question about Crocker-Harris's replacem...

question about Crocker-Harris's replacement (Gilbert)



Something seemed odd to me that such an affable, extroverted, kid-loving chap as Gilbert would really "suffer an attack of the jitters" and want to "practice his class lecture in the classroom beforehand".

So, especially since Gilbert, the student of "human behavior", has had his eye on Crocker-Harris's rather inhumane treatment of the kids and his lack of success with them, I'm wondering if Gilbert actually simply followed Crocker-Harris into the classroom deliberately, in order to "accidently" spill the beans about C-H's nickname. Perhaps he knew that C-H needed a bit of a heads-up in order to change his teaching style for his next job.

What do you think?
.

reply

I don't think he did it to get any kind of reaction from him. He said he was interested in human nature, so he probably wanted to see if C-H;s demeanor was for real or just a game face he put on. He probably assumed the man was already aware of that epithet, and if so, took pride in being so stern and intimidating. He certainly felt awful when he saw he was wrong, that C-H didn't know. Heartbreaking scene.

Since no one else answered in nearly two years, you'll have to accept my interpretation, lol.


"Well, for once the rich white man is in control!"C. M. Burns

reply