MovieChat Forums > I Love Lucy (1951) Discussion > Things that are so Far Fetched that they...

Things that are so Far Fetched that they are annoying


1. In Be a Pal, the donkey in the living room. Really? That thing would have peed and crapped all over the floor. It's bad enough we are supposed to believe she got all those other props. but the Burro was just overkill

2. In Kleptomania at the end she brings a Baby Elephant out of the bedroom. Same problem as above except even more unbelievable.

In general for a housewife without a Charge-A-Plate Lucy does have quite a lot of access to costumes of every sort, even things that most likely would not be in Fred's Vaudeville Trunk...like in pioneer women they all had outfits and she had a bathtub on legs in the kitchen. In the one where she grew got the beard stuck, she had a harem girl outfit...but I digress....

reply

These things are absurd, but I don't really find them annoying, because it is not a realistic show, everything that happens is a bit crazy.

reply

Maybe I should rephrase then. Things that were so absurd that they made no sense no matter which way you looked at it, even in LucyLand they made no sense. Most of the show is far-fetched and most of the situations Lucy gets into are far-fetched and unbelievable and absurd I agree. But my question is, like my examples, were there certain things where it was just totally over the top- maybe annoying was the wrong word. Like a Baby Elephant in the Bedroom was so over the top and unbelievable that I'm surprised it stayed in the script. Jess Oppenheimer made sure there was logic and credibility in the scripts from what I have read. Where did she get it? How did she get it in there? How did she clean up after it? Not even funny at all for theh ending of Kleptomania.

reply

well, i must admit i've never noticed much logic or credibility in it myself. Bizarre things always seem to be happening. like when Lucy gets shut in the freezer for long enough to have icicles growing all over her. she'd actually be dead by that time. And is it credible that anyone would think lucy and ethel were women from Mars? or that Ricky would think that four people needed eight pounds of rice for dinner? And would anyone seriously expect an actress to keep taking spoonfuls of a health tonic while rehearsing a commerical? Surely they would just use water during rehearsals? it just goes on and on. i can scarcely think of an episode that doesn't have something absurd in it. i find it just doesn't bother me, though it would in a more realistic show.

reply

All those things you mention are indeed absurd but fit with the plot. The whole show is absurd. However putting 8 pounds of rice in for 4 people by men who don't cook, while absurd, is not nearly on the level of absurdity of having a baby elephant in the bedroom! This is the kind of things I was looking for- not the regular absurd things in all the scripts, but things so outside the "normal absurdity" to be just plin stupid like the elephant in the bedroom. Almost as if the writers were really not thinking at all. In all the scenarios you mention there is plausibility in Lucy land.

reply

The entire show is basically a live action cartoon on a similar level of "Gilligan's Island", "Bewitched", or "I Dream of Jeannie". For the kids that grew up with this show (and that's a lot of generations of kids), we accepted every bit of the domestic fantasy. Certain episodes appear to be based in reality but of course, those are the least favorite episodes (for me anyway). Imagine that Lucy discovers that handsome actor, Cornell Wilde is staying in the penthouse suite of the very hotel that she and her best friends are in. She sneaks into his room to get a look at him, gets trapped out on the balcony where she finds a bed sheet. She shreds and ties it together to form a rope to lower herself off the side of the building. The rope snaps and Lucy drops five floors to her death on the sidewalk below. What would the laugh track's 'uh oh' lady think?!







The most important thing is being sincere, even if you have to fake it. - Cesar Romero

reply

That's true it is a live action cartoon in a lot of sense. However, it really isn't quite like a cartoon either because things don't magically appear in thin air and Lucy never falls up 5 stories and jumps ten stories from the street to a balcony. For example in the Seance episode, an actual ghost didn't appear in the room. What if suddenly a plate started floating in the air in the living room by itself with no explanation behind it later? Would that fit in with I Love Lucy? It would fit in with a cartoon. Sci-Fi and fantasy is not part of it. I understand the situations are absurd like a cartoon. But let's say the cart she was under in Cornell wild's room started to float in the air and the food starting talking by itself? Would that not be more far-fetched for this show than usual? Or Bobby the busboy ripped off his real skin and was a real werewolf underneath (not a costume)? Or Lucy as Superman flew from one window to the other? We don't see that sort of thing that is in cartoons. The basis of all of the shows are in reality, although absurd.
This is the type of thing I was asking for in my opening post. It is similar to a plate flying around in the air by itself to me that she was able to go to a circus, steal a baby elephant, get it transported to the apartment, get the elephant up the stairs and into the bedroom. It doesn't go with the other absurd things!

If you can't the difference between that and Lucy getting trapped out on the balcony and using a rope of sheets to lower herself down than this thread is pretty useless because I think there is a BIG difference. We saw her tying the sheets and going down. We don't see her sneak into a circus and walk down the street hauling a baby elephant. I think the writers dropped the ball with the elephant scene.
I'm telling you I KNOW the show is absurd and deals with the ridiculous and all you posters keep coming back to tell me that the show is absurd and unrealistic. I KNOW that- I was looking for scenes where they went a little too far like the BABY ELEPHANT she stole.

reply

[deleted]

Giant loaf of bread

reply

I was hoping someone would mention the bread. That one always bugged me. I was never expecting total realism, but that was just stupid.

reply

Yep, same. The loaf of bread that was like what... 8 feet. C'mon... That was soooo over the top I never even found it funny. And even before the bread was in the oven, when they were kneading the dough, how it got bigger and heavier. Ok, sure dough expands in volume when it has yeast, but it doesn't get heavier, yeast only adds air making it fluffy.

reply

that was my sons' favourite episode when they were young,t hey thought it was hilarious. the loaf doesn't look very realistic, but i don't mind, it is funny.

reply

What would the laugh track's 'uh oh' lady think



Who was that "uh-oh" lady? Some people say it was Lucille Ball's mother but I think she was a plant to clue the audience in on something important.

But'Cha Are, Blanche! Ya'Are In That Chair!

reply

I heard her on an episode of "Leave It To Beaver" and "The Donna Reed Show".
Maybe it was Lucy's mother originally.




The most important thing is being sincere, even if you have to fake it. - Cesar Romero

reply

That's funny because I think I heard her on the "Burns & Allen Show" or maybe it was "The Jack Benny Show"; I can't remember but it was on Antenna TV, so it was one of those classic TV shows made around the same time as I Love Lucy.



But'Cha Are, Blanche! Ya'Are In That Chair!

reply

Who was that "uh-oh" lady? Some people say it was Lucille Ball's mother but I think she was a plant to clue the audience in on something important.

The "uh oh" Lady came from a recording of a studio audience RADIO show. No one knows who she is. It's been used for years to "sweeten" many laugh tracks, and can be heard in other shows besides ILL.

I read this in, I think, TV Guide, some 40 years ago in an article on "canned laughter."

As others have said, the laugh comes up in various shows of the era.

reply

Oh my, that makes sense. She's like an urban legend 😂

But'Cha Are, Blanche! Ya'Are In That Chair!

reply

Well, at least both the Democrats and the Republicans were represented.
LOL

reply

Ha ha lol I didn't even notice that! Donkey AND elephant!

reply

The time the giant bread shot out of the oven and pinned Lucy down across the room.

reply

That is not too bad because we know she used 13 pats of yeast instead of 3 and we keep seeing the bowl get bigger and bigger so at least there is a how and why and an explanation for the giant loaf. Once you have an explanation, it can be absurd.

However in that same episode, Lucy is going to watch Ricky come home in a cab or bus and disqualify him for using modern transport and win the bet. She goes outside and Ricky appears riding a horse. But hen just gets off the horse and goes inside, leaving the horse on the sidewalk. That is more totally unbelievable its annoying than the giant loaf of bread pinning. NO explanation for how the horse is supposed to get himself home etc.

reply

She goes outside and Ricky appears riding a horse. But hen just gets off the horse and goes inside, leaving the horse on the sidewalk


In that episode we don't actually see Ricky get off the horse: it's left to the audiences imagination to fill in the blank. I assumed since he rode the horse home, he'd leave it there and then ride it back to work.

Likewise, with the baby elephant since the audience is clued in that Lucy is going to teach Ricky a lesson because he thinks she is a kleptomaniac, the audience assumes that Lucy borrowed all of the props like the gun, jewelry, handbags etc., and more than likely borrowed the baby elephant from a friend or someone she knew at the circus. If the episode went along the lines that she really was a klepto then yes, there would be an assumption that she stole the elephant which then would lead to how did steal etc.

I do agree that a lot of the what happens on the show stretch the imagination. OTOH, the writers did a really good job on most episodes to explain what something was and why it was there, to set up the joke, so Lucy has a reason to do something this way or that.

The Passports episode was a good example: Fred brings up the old trunk, Ethel establishes that there's a hole in it, Lucy reinforces that for the audience when Ethel asks, "How will you breathe?" and she responds "there's a hole in it," before she gets in to the trunk.


But'Cha Are, Blanche! Ya'Are In That Chair!

reply

>>>If the episode went along the lines that she really was a klepto then yes, there would be an assumption that she stole the elephant which then would lead to how did steal etc.

She deliberately stole John Wayne's footprints.

reply

lisabong,
You're saying that as absurd as something is, it shouldn't defy logic. Lucy herself has commented, saying it ceased to be funny when it's no longer logical. I think with the examples you gave, it may be a fine line. In other words, it's absurd with the baby Elephant scenario but it's still psychically logical. The bread coming out of the oven from 8 ft of nowhere, does defy logic since it's not physically possible

reply

The pan grew to 8 feet too, along with the bread, and both came out of a two foot oven.

If that's less absurd to you than a baby elephant or horse I don't know what strange criteria you use.

reply

But she would still need like an eight-foot-deep oven for it to come out the way it did.

reply

The truly strange thing about the loaf of bread is that it is put into the oven on one pan (a sheet pan, if memory serves me) and later pops out on a different type of pan (the longest loaf pan in history).

reply

Some of the things that Lucy did and actually survived are far fetched such as following off a hotel balcony and landing in a palm tree or falling into a vat of starch at the laundromat.


Obviously this show was not too grounded in reality. But I love it!!

reply

Hi Lisa! Fancy seeing you here here, Ethel Mae!

reply

Though I would've accepted such crazy props on the show anyway, I just sort of assumed her connections in "show business" helped her out.

reply

How did Ricky electrocute Lucy since she took all the parts out of the tv set she was inside of?

reply

Here's another one. In the episode "Ricky and Fred are TV Fans" Lucy and Ethel are up on the roof wanting to cut the wire that connects to their TV set so that the boys will not be able to watch the fight. When Lucy cuts the wire, all the lights go off in the building but amazingly, the Ricardo Apartment and the rest of the building isn't affected. The lights never go off in the Ricardo apartment and Ricky and Fred continue to watch the fight when Lucy bursts in the door and one notices in that split second where she yells...."Help....we're being arrested....help!!!".....that the lights in the hallway are on as well. Big goof there on the writer's part that could have been easily explained by saying only the Upper floor of the apartment house was affected by the cutting of the wire. No explanation was given as to why the Ricardo Apartment had electricity while the rest of the building went dark.

reply

I thought that wire that Lucy cut was from the building next to it. Just before they notice the cop behind them Ethel was telling Lucy she thinks that the wire Lucy is holding is for the building next door, but Lucy thinks it's the right wire to their apartment building. Lucy never lets go of the wire while talking to the cop and then she cuts it to prove to him that they were trying to kill the power to the apartment building they were on top of to stop their husbands from watching the fights. She cuts it and it's the wrong wire and the building next it the lights go off.



But'Cha Are, Blanche! Ya'Are In That Chair!

reply

I also thought of another one:

How come Ricky always got up so early and why would he be home in time for dinner? He was a band leader working in a nightclub so he would be at work at the club during dinner time and wouldn't be back to really late and since they lived in NYC in the 50s. I read that nightclubs stayed open until 4 or 5am back then so why would he have to get up and go to work early in the morning?



But'Cha Are, Blanche! Ya'Are In That Chair!

reply

Sox, I often thought about that too. I remember an episode that focused on Ricky's coming home late and almost never getting to spend time with Lucy. But on most episodes, his work hours were portrayed in a way that made him seem like a typical 8-5er. This was surely done to let him seem like a common man with a regular job. They alluded to him working at night, but there sure were a lot of episodes that must have taken place on Ricky's night off from the club.










Why don't we just shoot 'em down and be through with it?

reply

I think you have to imagine you are watching the show one a week, as it originally aired, not as situations occurring on an everyday basis

reply

The giant loaf of bread is funny, but yeah that was one of the worst absurdities. There's no way that it could fit in the oven and even if it puffed out after the oven door was open, it was perfectly baked on all sides. If it truly was all smushed in the oven, there would be large sections unbaked. A sight gag, but truly absurd.

reply

Plus, of course, the pan growing as well...

reply

Lucy and Ethyl dressed as hillbilly hags as Fred and Ricky's dates. The suspension of belief that they didn't know it was them. Too much to carry the comedy.

reply