MovieChat Forums > Gone to Earth (1950) Discussion > Blu-Ray/HD/Restoratio n forthcoming?

Blu-Ray/HD/Restoratio n forthcoming?


With many Archers-films seeing re-releases, is this one in the pipeline?

reply

Not that I've heard of. They're currently working on The Tales of Hoffmann and after that they will probably do Black Narcissus

The one available from Amazon UK at http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B000059RNP/papas-21 is the best available for home use at the moment.

That print was made some years ago by someone working for Disney - but then the suits decided not to release it and shelved it for a few years until it turned up on this DVD. The DVD also includes some behind-the-scenes "home movies" short on 8 or 16mm but without commentary (music soundtrack added for the DVD), so it helps to know who everyone is in the crew as well as the cast

Steve

reply

What a shame. :(

There was a retrospective last year over here, which a friend attended, and he said one was only shown on a fainted 16mm print, as it was too hard to find on 35mm. I guess it could be a while, then. :(

reply

Where is "here"? It's available on a decent 35mm print. I've seen it at a few festivals and special screenings

Steve

reply

:o

Berlin, actually. Maybe I am wrong (a friend attended them all), but there was one where he told us that it was a pretty mangled 16mm print, as nothing else turned up. :(

Oh, and thanks for frequenting those boards - it seems hard nowadays to get a lot of info on old films. :)

reply

Ah yes, one of our Powell and Pressburger Appreciation Society [http://www.powell-pressburger.org/] members also attended that retrospective and also complained about the quality of some of the prints they got.

There are better quality prints of Gone to Earth available. Maybe the organisers of the Berlin event didn't ask the right people

Steve

reply

The Korean DVD Amazon sells is excellent, with good vibrant colors and removable Korean subtitles. Plays in all region codes and does not require an all-region player.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000A0KXGQ/ref=olp_product_details?_encoding=UTF8&me=

It's utterly ridiculous that 20,000-plus people have rated "Red Shoes" and barely 700 people have rated this incredibly romantic, beautiful and poetic, technicolor masterpiece. In the original British cut on the Korean DVD, not the American version "Wild At Heart" butchered by Selznick who even sued to butcher the English version but lost the case.

So far, almost every single Powell-Pressburger or Michael Powell film I've seen is either a flat out classic or very close to it.

1) The Red Shoes - 10/10
2) Black Narcissus - 10/10
3) Life & Death of Colonel Blimp - 10/10
4) Tales of Hoffmann - 10/10
5) Stairway to Heaven aka A Matter of Life & Death - 10/10
6) Gone To Earth - 10/10
7) The Small Back Room - 10/10
8) Thief of Baghdad - 10/10
9) Age of Consent - 10/10
10)I Know Where I'm Going - 9/10
11)Edge of the World - 8/10
12)Canterbury Tale - 8/10
13)Peeping Tom - 7/10
14)Spy In Black - 7/10

reply

I notice that you rate the B&W films lower than most of the colour films.
B&W can be as beautiful and dramatic as colour

BTW it should be A Matter of Life and Death (AKA Stairway to Heaven) 

It's original title was A Matter of Life and Death. It was renamed as Stairway to Heaven for the American release because the US distributors thought that nobody would go to see a film with "Death" in the title, especially so soon after WWII.

How is it titled in Korea?

Steve Crook
The Powell and Pressburger Appreciation Society (PaPAS)
http://www.powell-pressburger.org/
https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/PnP/info

reply

I tend to like "Stairway to Heaven" better because it's the same title as the #1 most popular classic-rock song of all time.

It's the same title on the Korean-import https://www.amazon.com/Matter-Death-Stairway-Heaven-Korean/dp/B00BIJ0FC0/ref=sr_1_1?s=movies-tv&ie=UTF8&qid=1483483028&sr=1-1&keywords=a+matter+of+life+and+death+korean

although that film has now long been available in a "director's cut" U.S. version coupled with "Age of Consent":

https://www.amazon.com/Films-Michael-Powell-Stairway-Consent/dp/B001IZNIV4/ref=sr_1_1?s=movies-tv&ie=UTF8&qid=1483483309&sr=1-1&keywords=a+matter+of+life+and+death

Needless to add, "Age of Consent" promoted as a softcore "sex film" with the image of a young, nude Helen Mirren covering nearly the entire DVD box cover

https://www.amazon.com/Age-Consent-Anniversary-James-Mason/dp/B00VX21VZC/ref=sr_1_1_twi_dvd_2?s=movies-tv&ie=UTF8&qid=1483483276&sr=1-1&keywords=a+matter+of+life+and+death

has more than 10 times the sales (3,100 amazon sales rank vs. 37,000) of the double-dvd of "A Matter of Life & Death"/"Age of Consent" with the picture of Michael Powell on the cover and nudity only suggested in a small photo. Yes, the price of the double-set is around 3 to 4 dollars more but for that you get "A Matter of Life & Death" as extra, which is an all-time classic film with zero sex in it and only old-fashioned romance woven through a multi-faceted and philosophically challenging story line.

reply

Led Zep denied any connection between their #1 hit and the American title of the film 

I dislike it when advertisers promote things as "the Director's Cut" especially when the director had died 5 years before DVDs were invented. It's really just another print made from the same tired old negatives. We're still waiting for (and hoping for) a true restoration like Scorsese's Film Foundation did with The Red Shoes, The Life and death of Colonel Blimp and The Tales of Hoffmann. Any other P&P films advertised as "Restored" or a "Director's Cut" are an advertising con. They usually just mean that someone has made a new print with any actual restoration.

But that Sony DVD of A Matter of Life and Death and Age of Consent is the best print currently available, despite the mistake in AMOLAD. The second time Conductor 71 goes to Earth, the camera focusses on Bob and we see him in B&W slowly changing to being in colour. On the Sony print they left him in B&W. But you have to know the film very well to notice it.

Back to Gone to Earth, yes, it's a shame it's not better appreciated. It's a beautiful film, but it is quite melodramatic. I blame the original book. Mary Webb specialised in romantic melodrama

There is a good DVD of GTE available. It's a Region 2 DVD (UK & Europe) and it's the best copy available.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B000059RNP/papas-21

It includes "behind-the-scenes footage", home-movie style footage of the making of the film (without commentary so you have to know who everyone is).

Steve

reply

I don't agree about GTE, not even remotely.

Melodrama acknowledged, with the consummate skills of the true artist making the hardest things look easy, as a dis-ease born of certain prejudices and mindsets and values, and transcended, is no longer harmful but beneficial, especially when its criticism is tempered with as much affection as Powell brings to the Jennifer Jones character here.

Melodrama or more precisely and foundationally the long-outmoded, at-least-20-century-old, necessity of "dramatic form" itself, taken from a certain type of literature back when change through technology was at a snail's pace and later literature-influenced "life" (not life itself in its immense and paradoxical complexities which almost every single film seeking a large audience is FORCED and REQUIRED to ignore in favor of "drama" or never financed, "Waking Life" being the only exception in the past 20 years I can name outside the art-house scene), is one of the most cliched prisons of faux-&-outmoded "saying-nothing-new-anymore," non-metaphor-expanding "art" you can ever be sentenced to. The electric chair is better than that. lol The electric charge preferred by someone like Powell of pretending you care about "drama" while letting style do all the heavy spiritual lifting, transcending every last bit of it. Some call it visual poetry but "drama" has nothing to do with it.

I don't like any film because it so-well fits the conventions of drama. I consider all conventions of drama, not just 'melodrama' obsolete and done-to-death for 2000 years. Therefore, visual poetry is the first yardstick and "dramatic effectiveness" only the 19th or 20th down the line. Hence why I love Antonioni films that have almost no conventional drama at all and are hated by even artists of the stature of an Orson Welles, himself only great to the extent that he transcended the putrid stink of "drama." lol

Transcending using the skill-sets of the greatest artists then gives the person who makes the effort to perceive that phenomena, that special re-arrangement and placing of things significant over and above the film's a-thousand-times-hackneyed "dramatic content," and even to a certain extent, the passive consumer of cliched dramatic nonsense, MORE awareness of life, which is never set in stone and always changing (and nowadays at a very fast rate compared to the age that gave birth to "drama"), yet has definite rules that must be obeyed if it is to be tamed, through art and science and all overlaps in between.

Temperance is not compromise. Never has been, never will be. The Greeks taught that over 2000 years ago while they were analyzing and codifying the "dramatic form" itself and almost every other art-form we still use today, most out of habit than necessity. And as you well know, temperance is the absolute OBSESSION of the British and hence why Powell understands and uses it so effectively to subvert dogmatic convention from every side of the film-makers' palette and create his own, uniquely new and detailed maps of spiritual territory previously not navigable, or not navigable with as much ease, exuberance and joy, the rewards of a cartography well-done but never ending.

P.S. The Korean DVD is almost certainly a legal copy of the English one licensed for Korea, but since the English one is so cheap, I'll be buying that one too to see if there is any difference.

reply

It was released by Kino Lorber on blu-ray in the United States earlier this year. It has a really nice transfer and the blu-ray also has The Wild Heart on it.

https://www.amazon.com/Wild-Heart-Blu-ray-Jennifer-Jones/dp/B0776K3MX2

reply