MovieChat Forums > Cinderella (1950) Discussion > Not gonna lie, Cinderella's kinda a weak...

Not gonna lie, Cinderella's kinda a weak character


I get she was abused, but she basically has to be saved from everything. The Fairy Godmother and the mice and the prince do everything for her.

But thankfully for us casual viewers the mice were funny and Lucifer and Lady Tremaine were great villains.

reply

You should see the second sequel where she does a lot for herself(If you haven't already).

reply

Yet another cliché (and ignorant) comment. I'm not even gonna try to argue, because there are tons of articles about this topic online. Here are a few:
http://moviepilot.com/posts/2728446
http://www.fanpop.com/clubs/disney-princess/articles/233062/title/defense-dps-snow-white-cinderella (for those that ignorantly think Snow White is "weak", as well)
http://www.fanpop.com/clubs/disney-princess/articles/230909/title/why-cinderella-best-classic-princess
"Weak"? More like one of the strongest fictional characters ever created.

reply

The article defending Snow White, does not really do a good job at defending its thesis, and instead comes off like a high schooler's blog post.

HI-F___ING-YA
Nicholas Cage Deadfall
Oscar Predictions 2016 imdb.com/list/ls033120110/

reply

comes off like a high schooler's blog post.

No, that sounds more like the OP that posted this thread. Either way, Snow White is still a great character.

reply

Really? I don't remember the mice, fairy godmother, or prince doing her chores. I don't remember them sharing in the blame when gus accidentally got into tue teacup.

If you're happy and you know it, go sit in the corner and think about your life.

reply

You really expect she would punch her stepmother and stepsisters when they started to rip her dress?

reply

I think she was nice, strong and hard working. Plus you have to keep in mind when this was made. Women didn't exactly stand up for themselves back then. I think she pretty much worked hard and deserved her happy ending just like most Disney princesses, with the exception of Jasmine who came across as a spoiled brat at times. I find it weird how people have a problem with Cinderella but no problem with Jasmine who seemed to do nothing but whine a lot. I think second to Ariel's daughter in the Little Mermaid 2, who was also a whiny brat Jasmine is my least favorite princess.

"I'd rather lose for what I am than win for what I ain't"

Kacey Musgraves "Pageant Material"

reply

Jasmine was really lonely and bored and was pressured to get married before her next birthday.
So I feel that she had the right to not be happy about her situation.

reply

How is Jasmine a spoiled brat?

Sure, she's not as even-tempered as the usual Disney princess, but about 9/10ths of her screen time is spent reacting to some jerk trying to push her into a marriage she doesn't want. And that, at times, includes Aladdin himself.

reply

Good points.

reply

by Vberne » Tue Feb 2 2016 20:52:45
IMDb member since February 2015
I get she was abused, but she basically has to be saved from everything. The Fairy Godmother and the mice and the prince do everything for her.

But thankfully for us casual viewers the mice were funny and Lucifer and Lady Tremaine were great villains.

It's a good movie. What the hell's your problem with it?

reply

She was strong in the sense that she was patient enough to put up with that sorry excuse for a family. She was mistreated but never lost it. She stayed calm and remained that kind young woman she was.

I applaud her for that b/c I for one couldve NEVER dealt with that shit. Especially for 5+ years. I have very limited patience for people who treat me that way.

reply

But gave you ever been in a situation where you had to choose between homelessness, or taking abuse?.

Because those WERE Cinderella's options, until she married the prince.

reply

Indeed.
But it seems like people don't get that Cinderella didn't have the same options as they do.

reply

Seriously, what exactly did you expect Cinderella to do?
It is not like she could just leave the house and live somewhere else back in those days.

reply

Not to go into the difficulties of servants in centuries past, but that's not the only reasons she stayed. The house should have been hers by right - it had been her father's property and she was her father's only living child. So if she stayed, it was partly because if she left without a reference she'd find it impossible to get to another job, partly because the place was her rightful home in every sense, and partly because once she left she'd lose any claim to the social status she was born to, and be a permanent part of the servant class. Or worse.

Not that you'd get any of that from this version of the story.

reply

No, it is not really explained in detail in this version.
But it makes sense when you think about what it would have been like in real life for a girl in Cindy's situation.
Thank you!

reply