MovieChat Forums > The Secret Garden (1949) Discussion > Is there a Secret Garden expert who can ...

Is there a Secret Garden expert who can help me?


I've been looking for a version of this movie that I saw as a child. It's all a little fuzzy, but one thing that I do remember is Mary sleeping in Colin's room with him and that being how she got caught being somewhere that she was told not to go.

Is this that version? If so, I'm so happy I've found it, but if not, do you happen to know what version it is?

If you don't have anything nice to say, please, don't jump on people with your negativity.

reply

well, i haven't seen this one or the one from 1987 in years, but i'm pretty sure something very similar to that happens in the 1993 one

all i know is this one's my favorite, although the 93 one was great

reply

I just watched it, and there was a segment when she sang him to sleep. I have never seen the remake as I enjoyed this one so much from my childhood. I don't enjoy remakes unless they also change the story in some way. I loved the actor who played Dicken, but found very little info on him, except that he was originally from Yorkshire, so his accent was real. Marvelous movie!!!

Mary
"Believe in the magic of your dreams"

reply

There is a similar scene to the one you mentioned in the 1993 version. However I believe that it happens in Mary's room since Colin had to walk back in the morning since none of the people that worked at the manor knew he could walk yet.

reply

What Megan said. Note that Mary & Colin did not get caught, but it was a close call. In the book, she did sing him to sleep when she visited him in his room the first night, but she did not get caught.
Even in the movie, when Colin was sneaking back after spending the night in Mary's room, I think what he was hiding was the fact that he could walk, not that he and Mary were friends - he felt perfectly entitled to have Mary brought to keep him company in his room.
In the book, Martha found out Mary & Colin were friends because the next day at breakfast, Mary told Martha that she had met her cousin Colin. Then when Martha went to Colin's room later that day, he told Martha she had to bring Mary to see him whenever he wanted. At that point they did not tell Mrs. Medlock about it, but one day when she & the doctor walked in on Mary sitting with Coin, Colin did not even care about being found out - he just went into young Rajah-mode and anounced that the house staff was to bring Mary to him whenever he wished.
In the 1993 movie version, Martha finds out that Mary & Colin are friends before the other staff, because she sees Mary's foot sticking out from under Colin's bed when Martha & Medlock show up to give Colin his electrical leg stimulation treatments (those treatments were not in the book or other movies at all, but I actually thought it worked, so am not complaining). The later when Colin was having a fit and Mrs. Medlock was out, Martha resorted to bringing Mary to Colin's room to see of she could calm hin down. Which she did. Medlock arrived back to find Mary in Colin's room, and ordered her out, but Colin countermanded her.

reply

dont know about it, but I see in IMDB that Dorothea Brooking who made the BBC tv series of 7 episodes in the 1970's also made a tv series of it in 1960 and 1952! and most of those are lost episodes. perhaps you may have seen one of those early versions. Anyway, this 1949 version is fantastic. they didn't make it as a children's film, but as a film for everyone. like Wizard of Oz or Cukor's Little Women - and so these films are deeper, richer, more complex than those made as lighter children's fare. and thanks to all for the info.

reply