How Brave for 1949?


This movie somewhat attacked racism but didn't go that far. I assume this was due in part that it would have played in thousands of theatres in the then-Segregationist South. Thus is sort of dance around the subject. Remember that a year earlier an otherwise friendly crowd in Texas booed when President Harry Truman, campaigning for re-election, shook hands with a black woman.

Were there any other movies of this period that took on racism? Did they go as far as this one, or farther?

reply

"Pinky" starring Jeanne Crain and Ethel Waters goes farther. It's the story of a Black girl passing for White. It's definitely worth checking out.

reply

Saw it just recently. Great film.

reply

They were trying to prevent a mob from from hanging and burning "the *beep* who murdered my brother," and in the process examining their own prejudices and values. In what way is that dancing around racism?

In the "Pinky" vein there is also the 1959 version of "Imitation of Life," again with a white woman in the role of the passer. Much better IMO is the 1934 version--better acting all around, and the passer actually IS a light-skinned black woman.

reply

The original Imatation Of Life also has the deameaning Pancake Lady image. "Miss Bea I don't want no money, I just wanna be yo made". The 59 version is better.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

What are you talking about? Juano Hernandez is most certainly a black man, albeit one born in Puerto Rico (as if that should matter). A great actor, too.

reply

He was "black enough" that he wasn't allowed to stay in the same lodging as the rest of the main cast.

I just watched this movie, and it's as good as I remember.

** John Winchester doesn't bowl strikes -- he just knocks down one pin and the rest faint!

reply


True. I watched it today, and it was a revelation for me, because they don't show something like this often enough. Faulkner wrote about the people he knew and grew up with; good, bad and indifferent. Nothing sugar-coated here. The good: Claude Jarman, Jr, Juano Hernandez, Elizabeth Patterson, David Brian and Will Geer as the just-minded Sheriff who makes sure that the dead man's body is removed from it's second, watery grave to prove that Hernandez was not the murderer. The bad: most of the townspeople, who liberally use the 'n'-word, and are ready to burn Ms. Patterson, as she stands guard at the jail with her shotgun. A quietly touching scene for me was the venerable character actor, Porter Hall, bending over the body of his dead son, and cleaning the muck off his face and eyelids - and then breaking down completely. When Robert Osborne mentioned that item about Mr. Hernandez, after the film's close, I thought that at that in point time, the film's climate mirrored the actual racial climate of Oxford, Mississippi. Were Mr. Hernandez not an actor, and safely ensconced within the black quarter of the town (since, unfortunately, he had no other recourse) would his fate have been similar as Mr. Beauchamp's at the outset of the film? A proud, intelligent and independent black man resented by the white population because he lived with dignity, and was far above many of them? It gave me food for thought.

reply

Since I was a child in the deep South during the 1950s and 1960s I remember segregation and the struggles of the civil rights movement.

I saw 'Intruder in the Dust' for the first time yesterday. It was a bold, honest film, not only for it's era but for any time.

http://vincentandmorticiasspeakeasy14846.yuku.com/directory

reply

NO WAY OUT A 1950 movie starring Sidney Portier & Richard Widmark. A black doctor tends to a white racist patient at a prison ward. This is a very powerful movie. Portier's second movie & his first lead starring role.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0042792/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEsRfQd9lbw

reply

They Won't Forget Lana Turners first movies. Based on a true incident.

In this Our Life 1932 Bette Davis

Sgt Rutledge

I want to add I disagree about Imitation of Life. The first version is far more superior. The black woman is a equal business woman with the white women. She is not a maid like in the second version. She takes care of the pancake business and the other takes care of the syrup.

And in the original she is treated equally among the white women friends and associates. In the remake they treated her like a child and her best friend seemed to be the teenage daughter. Oh poor Annie.

Also in the original the white women and her friends took more interest in the way the daughter was treating her mother. In the remake Oh poor Annie. And last but not least there is no excuse they had to have a white woman pass for a black women when the original had a black woman play the daughter. The remake is like Hollywood regressed IMO.

reply

Just reading your post and thank-you for the insight of this film. I do enjoy the remake, and better understand that it was vehicle for Ms. Turner, after reading your post. Could it represent life? Yes. But what I am finding now, is that there were more films of racial tolerance and acceptance in the history of film. That doesn't mean equality, but more portrayed people with common decency. I hope to see the original (Imitation of Life) some day.

If we can save humanity, we become the caretakers of the world

reply

And I always tell people it is not that terrible Keven Costner movie. Whitman and Poitier were best friend in their personal lives. Whitman might have been the most racist character I have seen in a movie. Another 2 movie is Intruder in the Dust and Home of the Brave,with the great James Edwards.

reply

You mean Widmark

reply

Odds Against Tomorrow with Harry Belafonte is a movie of this era that confronts racism.

reply

"To Kill a Mockingbird".

"If I don't suit chu, you kin cut mah thoat!"

reply

The Well (1951) Pretty potent.

reply

I just borrowed Intruder from the library, but haven't seen it yet. I'm looking forward to watching it though. I have seen Pinky and No Way Out . In fact I watched them last year, great classic films. I think there is another film that deals with race called Steel Helmet or something like that.

reply

I watched it yesterday, wow the eyes that must been raised in the 1940's, that was heart wrenching when the father pulled his dead son out of the quicksand and discovered he was killed by his other son. Wonderful film!

reply

Great way to ruin the movie for anybody who hasn't seen it . . well done . .

reply

I agree, especially from an imbd member since '04. Obviously that's a critical scene and, no doubt, comes near the end. I haven't seen the movie and it's coming up soon on TCM and I was looking forward to viewing it primarily because of the terrific trailer I saw after watching 'Steel Helmet'>(two thumbs-up).It's disappointing, but I suppose I will be criticized for visiting the message board, however there's a reason that the "Spoiler" alert is available when commenting.

reply

My goodness, you don't think the movie attacked racism enough? What more could they have done? That was the whole point of the movie.

There are, of course, a lot of examples I can point to but the biggest of all is how differently everyone behaved when a black man was thought to have killed a white man than when it was revealed the real murderer was another white man; the victim's own brother. The discussion Chick and his uncle have about the people running away also speaks volumes.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply