MovieChat Forums > Rope (1948) Discussion > Don’t watch the trailer before seeing th...

Don’t watch the trailer before seeing the film!


The trailer included on the Blu-ray is rather interesting, if you have already seen the movie. It includes a scene set in the park that was obviously never intended to be in the actual film. The murder victim (who of course never gets a line of dialogue in the movie, unless you count his screams as the movie begins) is shown chatting in the park with his girlfriend (who is in the film). They part ways, planning to see each other at the party that night—and then Jimmy Stewart appears to tell us that they will actually never see each other again.

I’m honestly not at all sure how I feel about this kind of marketing angle. I mean that not as criticism, necessarily: I’m genuinely torn.

But the end of the trailer is a travesty. In the “making of” featurette, there was speculation that the underlying unspoken homosexuality might have been responsible for the film’s lack of box office success. But how about showing the climactic scene in the trailer? I tend not to like trailers in general for how much they spoil movies, but I’ve never seen anything like that before. Even if the movie studio doesn’t care about the artistic/creative reasons not to spoil the ending, why would you expect audiences to flock to a film when you have spelled out the climax in no uncertain terms? Puzzling.

reply

Because Hitchcock wanted the movie to be about concepts of morality and political philosophy, not just about a whodunit thriller...

the idea was to try to get the plot out of the way... even at the begining of the movie we know who committed the crime, why and how...

But audiences and, arguably moreso critics, didn't want to engagge with the movie on that level... Even today when you read commentary on the movie it's about the editing and such.... not about what the themes of the movie dealt with... About the nature of unaccountable and amoral privilege...

reply

It’s obviously not a “whodunit”: we see who done it from the opening scene.

But what we don’t see until very late in the movie is Jimmy Stewart flipping open the chest. Nor do we see a gun until late, not to mention one of the killers fighting for it with Jimmy Stewart and firing off a shot. But all that is in the trailer.

And I firmly believe Hitchcock did not want there to be zero tension about whether Stewart would ever see inside the chest (or, for that matter, whether he might even sympathize with his former students, based on his earlier comments). So I’m very glad I didn’t see that before watching the film.

reply