The film within a film


I guess we aren't really supposed to pay too much attention to the film that's being made during the course of this film, but I do have to mention it's kind of weird. In the early part of the film within the film, Esther Williams and Cyd Charisse appear to be two exotic native girls fighting over the handsome Navy Lieutenant. Then later, Cyd Charisse's character seems suddenly to have become a dancer in a nightclub, and Esther Williams' character a show-biz swimmer doing a water ballet. At the end of the ballet, we even see Cyd's character in contemporary Western dress. It's really kind of ood, but than I guess it's just not supposed to make any sense.

reply

Maybe it's a film within an film within a film!

reply

It all makes about as much sense as the Broadway musical being put together in "The Band Wagon."

reply

the calla lillies ah in bloom again... such a strange flowah. [stage doah]


reply

Sounds like you have watched this movie about as many times as I have - not that I particularly like it. But at this point, trying to figure out the film within this film is fairly amusing. The director is such a lame-o. Seems like Esther Williams movies end up being background noise at my house whenever they are run on TCM!

John 3:16

reply

I love Esther Williams movies. This one was my favorite until I saw Thrill of a Romance.

reply

I also love Esther Williams. But I can barely tolerate Peter Lawford, who was NEVER an actor. Consequently, On an Island with You is the Esther Williams movie I like least. Esther was so enormously talented and pretty that people never really gave her a chance as a legitimate actress. That is a great pity. I wish she had left us more films as well as more varied films to enjoy her great charisma on the silver screen.

John 3:16

reply