MovieChat Forums > Joan of Arc (1948) Discussion > Chopped version on TCM

Chopped version on TCM


I thought TCM was going to show the restored, 145-minute version today. Clearly, we're seeing the cut one, with odd fadeouts and the narration throughout.

Have they ever shown the restoration on TCM?

reply

In addition the print of the version TCM ran was deplorable. The colors were faded and blanched. It was difficult on the eyes to watch this mess. It was certainly a huge disappointment that they showed such an inferior presentation when a restored pristine version is available.

TCM really bungled it.

reply

It was certainly a huge disappointment that they showed such an inferior presentation when a restored pristine version is available.

Especially when Osborne's introduction mentioned that the film had won an Oscar for Best Color Cinematography.

reply

I was appalled at this truncated version, which also looked as if a family of Burgundian peasants had eaten breakfast off the print. I subsequently ordered and received from Amazon a copy of the fully restored version and, having watched it tonight, can recommend that it was, indeed, worthy of its 7 Oscar nominations and wins for color cinematography and costume design (the first award ever bestowed in this category).

It's clear that the film was probably heavily influenced by the success of Olivier's Henry V, as least in look. The language, adapted from Maxwell Anderson's stage hit, sounds very stilted to a modern ear--sincere and well-meant, but more than a little too lofty and off-putting. Bergman is excellent and Ferrer is outstanding because they both manage to transcend the non-dimensionality of virtually every other character, especially the painfully obvious villainy of the grossly rotund Bishop of Beauvais.

"Thank you, thank you--you're most kind. In fact you're every kind."

reply

Did you see it today? Looked beautiful.

reply

I too was disapointed when TCM ran the 100min. faded version of Joan of Arc;
especially when I had been told that the only version worth watching was the new restored 145min. version.

They had the film scheduled again for March 13 along with 3 other movie versions of the Joan of Arc story. This time they ran the 145min. restored version and it looked fantastic!

Why they waited until tonight to run the restored version; 3 weeks after the previous run, I don't know.

Good things come to those who wait

Do you remember the spell?
Asa Nisi Masa... Asa Nisi Masa... sh!

reply

It's on right now on TCM. Ingrid looks like she has dark makeup on in much of this film. It doesn't look faded to me.

reply

Right TopFlight, this must be the restored version.

reply