MovieChat Forums > Mourning Becomes Electra (1947) Discussion > Have you noticed that RKO had a habit of...

Have you noticed that RKO had a habit of cutting their films--


--when they didn't do well?

They cut Orson Welles' "The Magnificent Ambersons" down to 85 minutes, they did the same thing with the 1941 version of "The Devil and Daniel Webster", they cut "Mourning Becomes Electra" to 105 minutes, and they cut the Ingrid Bergman "Joan of Arc" down to 100 minutes--all after they had either been unsuccessfully previewed, or released and flopped at the box office.

No other major studio that I can remember did this to so many films.

reply

That's very interesting. I'm glad you posted this. I've become a fan of RKO and didn't know that. I wonder what was their reasoning for it? Its a shame though b/c RKO was one of the few studios in the Golden Era that liked to step out on a limb and do films that no one else would do. The only other studio I can think of that liked to experiment was United Artists (UA) in their early days.

reply

I'm sure that RKO is hardly alone in cutting films. I think that because of Ambersons they just have a brighter spotlight on them.

reply

[deleted]

One of the most infamous cases was MGM and Thalberg cutting "Greed" from von Stroheim's 4 and half hour version (which he cut from 9 hours) down to just barely over 2 hours. And then they burned the outtakes for either the silver or the space in the vault. And I am sure there are others.

reply

This O'Neill movie needed to be cut.

All of O'Neill is impossibly, mind-numbingly verbose.

reply

Movie girl: I am really disappointed when films are cut. Don't recall which studio cut the Dickens film portrayal - Great Expectations '34, but it was certainly annoying to view it with key scenes cut. In the early 80's I had taped the film on VHS = and needing a spare VHS, taping over it accidentally. I figured I could retape it! I was dead wrong. A few months later I found that Valerie Hobson's scenes as Biddy the governess were cut out and one with Pip and Miss Havisham. Later I bought the VHS professionally and still later the DVD - to get the entire film, but apparently when released they decided to use the cut version!
I cannot think why they would take a wonderful 30's film and 50 years later cut the scenes. I am going to see which studio put this out. VAlerie Hobson does
portray Estella in the 40's version of GE.

reply