Remake


This is almost a word for word remake of Mr. Wong in Chinatown(1939). It's not quite as entertaining, however.

reply

It isn't just almost word-for-word, they even used the EXACT SAME SETS and CAMERA SET-UPS! It's like re-staging a live play and only the actors have changed. I couldn't believe what I was seeing.

reply

Captain J... Captain K...

Well, we don't see the attempt to blow up Wong, I mean Chan, done by Jackson, I mean Kelso...

I like the very different delivery of the detective who plays the Street role here; "There'd be flash light bulbs all over the place", so casual compared to the harried delivery of Grant Withers. "I think the dumb act is just a gag", is another one... very different and unconvincing delivery compared to Street.

Oh, and we never see Chan say "Tea for the inspector, quickly!", to which the detective replies, "Tea! That's all I need!"

In Docks of New Orleans they remake Mr Wong Detective and one funny change is how in the first movie, Street asks someone some questions and the punch line is that he reveals himself to be the "office manager" of the murder victim, Dayton, the head of the chemical company. We don't often hear of "office managers" in any film, but this shows that this person had the authority to be in the victim's office so he had this purpose there, Street was behaving as if he was suspicious in knowing these things about the office and then was wrong-footed.

In Docks of New Orleans, this same "office manager" is brought up in the conversation between the three principals (before the first murder victim dies, Lafontaine instead of Dayton in the first film) about the agreement to deal with what happens "when one of us dies", and one of them says, "Your office manager, Thompson, I don't trust him!" and the other says "Why don't you fire him and make sure". I don't know but I have never heard of people in a film argue about an office manager being untrustworthy except for here!

reply

It's dire and the plot resolution leaves important questions unanswered. It's never explained why the Princess came to see Charlie (even if we can assume she's suspicious of Kelso), or how Kong and Kelso were meant to get away with the swindle if they themselves weren't planning to bump her off. Kelso tells Kong that the princess had given him a cheque for $250,000, but we're later told that the only cheque drawn in his name is for $100,000. Maybe the original Moto film clarifies the situation, but I couldn't bear the prospect of sitting through this dreck again.

reply

The screenplay by Scott Darling for both movies are just about identical. I liked his writing for the first three Mr Wong movies.

reply