Superb composition and cinematography
This was shown recently on TCM in HD and the video quality was remarkable: the color was brilliant, perfectly registered, and true. There must have been a restoration of this wonderful Technicolor work recently.
It's easy to see why it won Best Cinematography, Color and Best Art Direction - Interior Decoration, Color at the Oscars. The beauty is surpassing. The interior shots with the glow of the warm fire playing on the faces, and the candle on the table with the glowing circle of light on the surface are deeply striking. The close-ups of the fawn's rich short coat of fur also. The entire presentation is absolutely sensual.
Gregory Peck's Golden Globe is also well deserved. His depiction of the archetypal hard working but wise, caring father is absolutely wonderful. He is perfectly cast and at his absolute peak.