Major Bergmann


The film Roma, città aperta is a historically-based story of the Italian Resistance movement and its struggle against the Nazi occupation of Italy. It was written in 1943-44 by Robert Rossellini while Rome was still occupied by German forces, and the film was shot almost immediately after the city was liberated while the Germans still occupied the streets. Rossellini even includes actual footage of German soldiers marching at the foot of the Spanish steps in Rome. In this neo-realistic film, the depicted villains are clearly the Nazis, and more specifically Major Bergman, played by Henry Feist. Since it is one of the first films created that dealt with such subject matter, the film creates archetypes for certain characters. Feist's Bergmann is one of these archetypes; he epitomizes Nazism for future films.
Major Bergmann is portrayed as a merciless, cruel, and godless authority. He parades around arrogantly in his brown uniform with his egotistical smirk on his face. He expresses his idea of Germans being a master race. Hartman, a fellow officer, asks what will happen if Manfredi does not give the needed information before dawn. Bergmann replies, “Then it would mean an Italian is worth as much as a German. It would mean there is no difference in the blood of a slave race and a master race. And no reason for this war.” This idea is consistent with the ideology and practice of Nazism. Major Bergmann is personified as a Nazi not only by his uniform, but also in his demeanor and conduct. This film was written in the neo-realist spirit. Because of this some would argue that there is no need to recreate or form anything, but Rossellini did more than just film things as they existed; he created a mold.

Thoughts?

reply

[deleted]

Yes, I picked up on both of those characters, as I'm sure many did. Maybe it was just the Catholic nature of the film to depict a presumed homosexual as bad, since the Church preaches against it. Glad I'm not the only one noticing these things!
That aside, I thought this was a great film.

reply

oddly enough, despite the 'Catholic Nature' of the film, the Catholic church hated this film, as they did quite a lot of the neo-realist films - apparently because the ordinary people were not seen to be depending on the Church for help, but going out and doing things for themselves to gain their freedom. Also, despite the 'paths of God' bit, in the quotations, the Church also condemned a portrayal of one of their priests assosciating with and helping Communists. Myself, i didn't pick up the homosexual undertones in Bergmann, but then its been a while since i watched it. I personally thought that he was more or less just a device because the story requires an overall baddy, and someone to deliver the 'slave-race master-race' line.

reply

I didn't see any homosexuality in Bergmann, but it was definitely there with his female counterpart, and she seemed to me to be even crueler than Bergmann - a walking machine, psychopaths, the both of them no matter what their sexuality was.

reply

[deleted]

What do you know!!
I just posted a complain against Rosellini for the strange way he directed the major to seat on his desk with a totally womanly body posture. Or, if he wasn't gay maybe the italians wanted to give him an extra "insult", basing that on the values and social attitudes of the time.
The same goes for Ingrid and her open advances on Mina

If pigs had wings the sh*t of this world would be perfectly shared

reply

@ Abalalla

An interesting post. I think the mould created by Rosselini was not a Nazi archetype but the archetype of the conqueror who believes they are superior and justified in their actions over and against the inferior people they have subjugated.

I give my respect to those who have earned it; to everyone else, I'm civil.

reply

Hi Poppy, I have not viewed this particular film my self, but it is obviously the type of art I would enjoy.

If you haven't blocked me then please send me a PM.

I am a real person not a computer simulation. Who knows about the rest these days...

reply

Bergmann was played by Harry Feist, an Austrian dancer, and his characterisation is slightly effeminate. Decadent Nazi.

"Chicken soup - with a *beep* straw."

reply