MovieChat Forums > The Razor's Edge (1946) Discussion > Great theme poor execution !

Great theme poor execution !


It troubles me that so great a novel was so mishandled in this cinematic treatment. The story in my mind seems to be timeless, the quest for the meaning and purpose of ones life. Although there were moments that I thought were memorable,particularly the coal miner who reveals his inner turmoil and the encounter with the holy man in India, most of the film was less compelling. Although true in many aspects to the novel I felt the movie failed to provide the qualities that a film adaptation can offer, such as primarily interesting locations and lovely foreign vistas, instead we're given dinghy stage sets ! The film was certainly well cast , Power was inspiring, Tierney was manipulative and Webb was especially well cast as the society conscious expat. However, the role of Baxter's Sophie was somehow less effective given the poor production value she was presented with. In the novel her death Is devastating given the tragic events that led up to it in her earlier life, yet the film seems to provide little background to the murder therefore making its impact somewhat hollow. In my opinion, her demise should have been captured against a sweeping backdrop of seedy hotels found within French ports that cater to a world of sailors and their milieu. The same could be said for the passing of Webb as Templeton, we should have been shown his extravagant nature with shots of the Riviera and glimpses of his mansion, but instead we are witness to his death in a simple scene that takes place in his bedroom. The scope of this film was international and yet the production seemed remarkably humdrum considering the glorious avenues presented by the book. For me it was really an opportunity missed.

reply

I didn't read the book but watching the movie I saw all the things you said you missed. It was done through the telling of the story. I felt I got a good sense of who the characters why and what drove them.

To have included as much detail as you seem to think was needed would have not only made the movie a lot longer but also a lot more expensive to produce. The important think, in my opinion, is getting the mood and the message across. In that respect the movie was successful. Those who want more depth should read the book and use their own imagination to picture all the international scenery.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply

I agree with the other poster, I love TRE, but have also not yet read the novel.

I thought Baxter was wonderful, although I ant yet agree or disagree with you about the death in the novel's impact vs the film.

But I thought Uncle Elliot's death was well handled - the priest says how his sins were superficial, then the scene switches to the deathbed, where he is dictating his decline of the princess' invitation "owing to a prior engagement", which turns out to be his own death, which requires none of the pomp or pretense of his life, only a place in which to die, which turns out to be a different an bedroom. He had people there at the end, though, fulfilling the priest's statement that he wasn't such a bad guy stet all. What I'm saying is I thought his death and its surroundings were captured perfectly.

reply