MovieChat Forums > Peter and the Wolf (1946) Discussion > I think I know why it's not popularly re...

I think I know why it's not popularly refered to


some posters wonder why patw isn't more freely advertised than it is.It seems to portray wolves in a way that wasn't as challenged then as it is now.you wouldn/t want to show this cartoon in regions where wolves are being reintroduced- unless you want to get a lot of wolves shot. Especially the way Peter's being lionized & there's dancing in the streets because the same animal whose removal is being celebrated is being granted the privilage of expecting its reintroduction to be accepted. Potential conflict of interest

reply

I agree.was the cartoon se in the tundra?

reply

I believe it was set in Russia, where wolves were pretty abundant there in the post'war years & still greatly feared by the Russians.While it gives great credence to the impression that wolves were demonized in the past & angelified in the present. A few ironies to this would be, for example, the sitcom called The Munsters, where Grampa(the vampire) changed himself into a wolf & was nicer than he was in human form. Not that this goes very for, but the wolf was nabbed by a dog catcher & gave him no trouble. The way wolves were viewed then, you'd expect to wonder who was trying to catch who. This suggests a view of wolves ahead of its time. On tne other hand, I had to do a double take when I saw Beauty & the Beast to discern if the pack hunting canids terrorizing Belle, her father & the beast were supposed to be wolves, because their viciousness towards humans seemed a little retro. I was of the impression that it was common assumption that wolves were harmless to humans. Since that time, some incidences forced an altering of that assumption to an acceptance of the fact that wolves should be treated with caution & respect, like any other potentially dangerous animals. In some ways real wolves are more ferocious & deadly than the drooling, snarling villain of this miniclassic of 1946. He worked by himself & was only shown picking on a duck, a cat, a bird, & a boy, who are all less than half his size. He didn't team up w/ others of his kind & terrorize horses, cattle, or moose who are way more than twice his size

reply

Where are wolves being introduced? Aren't the regions they are being introduce mostly rural, therefore a lot less populated?

I would say that this film hasn't been released for quite some time is because the film lacks dialogue and relies entirely on music - from what I can remember, it has been over a decade since I last saw it.

reply

Being only 10 minutes, it probably hasn't gotten much visibility. I think a valid point would be to say that it's closing scene would not set well if viewed by peope who are protesting wolf reintroduction, which is happening in several areas. Namely the scene of dancing in the streets over the wolfs removal from the equation, in areas where wolves are being brought back into the equation.

There's only 1 Yogi Bear. Thet tried a 2nd time, & they made a Booboo!

reply

Replying to an ancient post... I know. :)

I'm introducing this story in my music class (we're talking about sound effects in stories and setting stories to music).

Anyway, even as old as this film is, if they had stuck to the book's ending, the wolf thing wouldn't be an issue. They caught the wolf and took him to the zoo! :)




"The crows seemed to be calling his name, thought Caw." --Jack Handey

reply

I,ve heard versions like that.They didn't say much one way or the other in this version did they. Nobody said the wolf was dead.

Kyle: It's bigger than Cartman's @$$!
Eric: No it isn't you guys

reply

No, I don't think they said for sure. :) I just meant that in the book that I read to the kids, it made a point to mention that they took him to the zoo. There was never a question about whether they killed him. That was a pretty happy ending for everyone (except the duck!).


"The crows seemed to be calling his name, thought Caw." --Jack Handey

reply


I think I heard of versions of that. The duck got out in some, in others it doesn't say one way or the other.
Kyle: It's bigger than Cartman's @$$!
Eric: No it isn't you guys

reply