MovieChat Forums > A Letter for Evie (1946) Discussion > Exceptionally hokey, awkward movie

Exceptionally hokey, awkward movie


Evie comes off as desperate in her firing shot to land a man -- ANY man! -- by getting the absurd idea (from secretarial pool coworker) that sticking a letter in an unknown soldier's shirt pocket, would lead to getting a pearl in an oyster! Edgar is also desperate and awkward in his low self-worth in pulling off the misleading coup-de-gras.

There's corny, bordering on outright hokey elements to this picture like the cat.

Perhaps there's cases of multiple miscasting. The tall, strong-chested "lumberjack" should have been a Clark Gable type and maybe a warmer type like Claudette Colbert could have done well. Actually, I found Evie's roommate Barney a more brazen and therefore, more interesting character, than meek, wishy-washy Evie. I tried thinking of other "ugly duckling" comedic actors who would done a better Edgar, but Hume does the trick here; a rare good casting (besides the actress playing Barney).




http://www.mgmbill.org/ Help protect boys rights, too!

reply

Loved this movie.

To your point, wasn't John Carroll indeed cast as the "lumberjack" type? And in fact, he is often referred to as a "Clark Gable" knockoff.

reply

Indeed, John Carroll was a Clark Gable "knock off."
When Clark Gable went to war, MGM began promoting John Carroll and James Craig (similar in looks, but a little less brash), in Gable type roles.
I think the movie is "cute," and especially always think when I have seen it, that women at the "home front" would have enjoyed the story line.
Everyone has a different opinion, I realize, but I think the movie rises above it's "B movie" status because of the strong cast, especially Marsha Hunt and Hume Cronyn.

reply

Agree on all your comments. And the great work done in the film by Marsha Hunt and Hume Cronyn (and John Carroll).

I was surprised by Hume's performance the most, as was used to seeing him in minor parts from other movies. Here he is basically the central character of the film and does it smashingly.

reply