MovieChat Forums > I Know Where I'm Going! (1946) Discussion > Slow at the start, but worth watching ti...

Slow at the start, but worth watching til the end!


I was pretty bored at the start of this movie, but it began to slowly grow on me. When Bridie comes to Joan and *spoiler ahead* justifiably blasts her for her reckless selfishness - WHOA!!! All the Scottish/British politeness & reserve flies out the window in a fiery scene. And when Torquil & Joan go at each other shouting moments later - WOW!!! I watched it again today, and to me it is a truly realistic & powerful exchange. After those scenes, things really get interesting. I'd never heard of "Corryvreckan" and thought it was movie fiction until I did an internet search and found out it's a real whirlpool, the 2nd largest in the world! Really glad I watched the whole thing.

reply

Those are two of my favourite scenes as well - I love the look on Catriona's face when Bridie is crying and Joan is imploring her to understand : reproach combined with wisdom, insight and empathy. And of course it's all followed by Catriona's wonderful,"She's running away from you!" line to Torquil. Glad to meet a new devotee, and welcome. This is my hands down no question about it favourite movie. There's a whole book about IKWIG on Amazon for $10.

reply

The other part of that that you should watch carefully is that when Bridie and Joan are arguing, Catriona is standing between them and she says more than the other two without saying a word. Pamela Brown was superb at that sort of thing. Check out her performance as Jane Shore, the King's mistress in Olivier's Richard III (1955) [http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0049674/]. She never says a word, but she speaks volumes.

It's a shame that Pamela didn't do more film work, she really was very good at it. It's unusual for someone who was primarily a stage actress to be able to work on film so well. She really did understand the difference and knew that in film it's all done with the eyes


The book, by Pam Cook, in the BFI Film Classics series, is very good. But like all the books in that series it's a personal view of the film rather than a thorough analysis.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0851708145/papas-20 from $6.50
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/0851708145/papas-21 £9.49
Pam Cook worked at the British Film Institute for 15 years and was associate editor of the leading film journal Sight and Sound from 1991 to 1994. She then joined the University of East Anglia as Senior Lecturer in Film before being appointed the UK's first Professor of European Film and Media at the University of Southampton in 1998. Following her retirement in February 2006, she became Professor Emeritus in Film at Southampton.

There's another book about this film, (By Eric Britton. World Film Publications: London, 1946). That was published just after the war when materials were still in short supply. It was also only published as a paperback. Consequently, not many survive. But they do appear in second hand book shops every now and then. It's a lovely little book and it tells the full story along with some additional information. It was written with the help of the film-makers although it wasn't written by them.

Steve

reply

I was taken with this movie literally from the beginning: the whimsical title sequence!

"You may very well think that; I couldn't possibly comment."

reply

The more I watch this film, the more I feel the beginning of the film (or at least the first 15 minutes) absolutely rocket past as like Joan, it knows where its going. Only when she is held up, does the film slow (in a good way) and starts to flourish organically. I feel this is one film that you just can't rush.

reply

My daughter, in her 20's, had this trouble as well. If you show this film to a friend, you must encourage them to stick with it.

reply