The Makeup


A number of commentators have noted that Dorothy McGuire, regardless of how dowdy and plain they attempted to make her look, remained basically attractive and this made implausible a number of scenes. Most notably,the canteen scene with the soldiers retreating upon seeing her was unconvincing.
However even Robert Montgomery's makeup did not render him the grotesque character he was supposed to be.I think the makeup of the two main characters clearly impacted the effectiveness of the film.

reply

It was Robert young not Ribert Montgomery. And as for looks that's what willing suspension if disbelief is all about.

reply

I really like this movie but I also thought the canteen scene was annoying. However, I thought so for the reason that the soldiers were real jerks. Anyone who would act like they did should have been horse-whipped - regardless of whether she was homely or not...

reply

[deleted]

All good points. I agree that she looked homely. I suppose something like that could've happened in real life, where someone was considered too homely by a group of people and maybe the writers of the story were recalling things they witnessed, or in Laura's case she just happened to be among a group of picky, impolite guys.

I'm surprised this thread started out as a critism of the makeup, because I thought the contrasts between "beautiful" and "unattractive" were perfect. I'm sick of films where they make a character like Oliver look overly grotesque to where it's unrealistic. In Oliver's case he was just different enough from before that HE considered himself to be less valuable as a person, which was part of the point.



reply

OK, first, I found it silly that the incredible transformation that turned DMG from "homely" to "beautiful" involved a slight touch of makeup and even slighter change of hairstyle. OK, whatever.
What truly strained the film's credibility was that canteen scene. I totally get it that they could not depict reality in 1945, BUT...
Reality: a dance where horndog soldiers outnumber the women and there's a woman who is sitting alone and she is simply "homely" and not suffering from having multiple noses or the worst acne known to medical science or LBJ ears or some other extremely lamentable facial crisis? She'd still have at least 3 of them vying for her favors.

I have seen enough to know I have seen too much. -- ALOTO

reply

Dorothy McGuire's character reminded me of Betsy Blair's character in "Marty", and also Olivia DeHavilland in "The Heiress". In all these cases, the woman wouldn't be considered "homely" at all, with different makeup and hair styling (and a soft focus lens, of course). So clearly, how a woman feels about herself and carries herself contributes to whether she is perceived as attractive or not. So after DMG's character gains more self-confidence, she could probably go to that same dance and not be perceived as repulsive by others meeting her for the first time. Or, at least, if the men treated her badly, she would now see it as a reflection of the men's own ugliness rather than hers.

I also recall a Star Trek episode in which three women were being delivered by the Enterprise to miners, to become their wives, on a desolate planet. The women were supposedly ugly until they took pills which supposedly made them beautiful. It turned out that the pills were a placebo and that they "became" beautiful when they believed they were beautiful. I like to think that eventually, the character seeing herself as beautiful will lead her to want to use makeup, pluck her brows, and fix her hair, which will make her even more attractive to others. It will give her the confidence to become the beautiful person she always had been.

Life is a banquet, and most poor suckers are starving to death!

reply

I agree absolutely. People's blatant reactions to them compared to their actual looks was very distracting. I've seen this in other films with a similar storyline. Remember Barbra Streisand in The Mirror Has Two Faces? LOL

reply

The fact that McGuire didn't look "homely" enough is a huge flaw in the film...as for Young...his view of himself made sense in that he exaggerated reality in his own mind. In those days, perhaps it was the Hollywood image consciousness of movie stars that prevented the studios from making them look too drastically horrific. They should have had either more makeup or completely different actors playing the "homely' characters. Audiences then were not used to seeing the type of grotesqueness that is seen today.

reply

I think those two were basically just presented as 'Hollywood ugly', because in real life, there wouldn't have been so much melodrama surrounding their love lives, LOL. I don't think so anyway.

reply

It's like putting glasses and a sweater on Donna Reed for the "what if" portion of It's a Wonderful Life. That's a librarian that would make me go to the library every day.

In the film I could see Dorothy as, maybe, a bit plain for the era, but it would take someone with absolutely no imagination to see that she was beautiful.

reply

I think the look is consistent with the theme of the movie. Yes, Dorothy McGuire is not hideous by any measure, but she has a "Pitiful Pearl" way of carrying herself that makes her seem unattractive. Also, so much of her "look" is caused by the lighting, which casts shadows across her face. (I remember reading that so much of Greta Garbo's own image in film was the amazing work by her lighting designer.

___________________________________
Never say never...

reply