MovieChat Forums > Caravan (1946) Discussion > Does *no one else* like this film?

Does *no one else* like this film?


I guess I'm having a hard time believing that this is the first post for this film (positive or negative).


I mean, a movie that ends with the bad guy drowning in quicksand in a very Victorian manner cant be all bad. :)

reply

So, its not like Caravan with a drum solo? Can't say I ever heard of it, but then I've only seen maybe 300,000,000 films.

What is the sound an imploding pimp makes?

reply


Can't say I ever heard of it, but then I've only seen maybe 300,000,000 films.


But not this one, apparently. ¬ _¬

reply

A fair amount of it is very cliched. A fair number of the lines sound either like someone who doesn't know how to write dialog or like someone trying to parody this sort of melodrama, i.e. are accidentally funny.

Amid the weak or slow parts there's a fair amount of adventure, a degree of humor and even some flamenco dancing. So it's okay.

The "party" that the cad gives his wife was unexpected and sort of weird. You'd think he wouldn't want to invite over a bunch of people who would get drunk and trash/rob his place.

Some of the British English is particularly difficult and even though I watch a lot of this kind of stuff I was yearning for subtitles.

reply

I think most of the reviews and comments are from people too cynical to 'get' the film. I recently saw it at the BFI Southbank in London with a packed audience, who laughed throughout, and were gripped by the action. I think, for what it was, escapist melodrama, it holds up fairly well.

---------------------------------------
Skating and sinning...

reply


I think most of the reviews and comments are from people too cynical to 'get' the film. I recently saw it at the BFI Southbank in London with a packed audience, who laughed throughout, and were gripped by the action. I think, for what it was, escapist melodrama, it holds up fairly well.


I'm glad to hear it went over well in the present-day UK!

Somehow-or-other, I dropped by Jean Kent's board after thinking about Caravan recently and what did I find? She introduced the screening you saw on her 90th birthday!

(Some people have all the luck!)

I'm hoping that the Criterion/Eclipse folks will see fit to release it on DVD at long last. They released a Region 1 DVD with The Man in Grey, The Wicked Lady, and Madonna of the Seven Moons late last year. With any luck, they might be releasing more of the Gainsborough melodramas on DVD this year; we'll have to wait and see.

Anyway, it's nice to hear that other people have both seen and appreciated this film. I was fortunate enough to see it twice on the Silver Screen, and while watching it on DVD isn't quite the same, it would be nice to be able to see it every year or two as the fancy takes one.

reply