MovieChat Forums > And Then There Were None (1945) Discussion > Best and worst?? New one on way?

Best and worst?? New one on way?


Just wanted peoples views on the best and worst version of this film, i am mixed, anyone know if there are plans for a remake? Cheers, Paul

reply

I think the time is right for a new version which will follow through to Christie's original ending - I believe today's audiences would accept it (she changed it herself when she dramatized it, believing, I think, that wartime British audiences had enough to depress them without a play that ended in a stage full of corpses!).

"I don't use a pen: I write with a goose quill dipped in venom!"---W. Lydecker

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

The russian version fron the 80's follows the book very closely, including having everyone die at the end, and it is an unmitigated bore. The characters, and I mean every one of them, are completely without humor. In the book, this creates a certain hypnotic mood and works beautifully, but on film, it's deadening. To be fair, the English titles were obviously translated by someone who does not speak english and was translating phoenetically. For example if the line is "The killer is one of us", the title reads something like "Killer the us of one is". And I'm not exaggerating! This is through the whole film! Really horrible. Lombard and Vera DO get to have sex though!

reply

[deleted]

The characters in the russian version are completely humorless which I found to be a drag; but even if you didn't, come on man, those english subtitles are deplorable. Also the movie didn't need to be over two hours long. Sorry, in my opinion, Rene Clair had just the right touch, and did it better.

reply

[deleted]