MovieChat Forums > Mr. Skeffington (1944) Discussion > Does diphtheria ever really age people l...

Does diphtheria ever really age people like that?


I realize that the screenwriters just needed some kind of plausible reason for Fanny to lose her looks so precipitously (kind of the opposite of the Glamorous Movie Star Death, that allows you to look great, in full makeup, on your deathbed). But - diphtheria? The only disfiguring side effects I could find in Medline were facial paralysis and swelling. In the movie Fanny ages thirty years and her hair falls out. Does anyone here know if this can actually happen?

reply

no, i think it's a bit of dramatic license...

my theory is that they needed a debilitating illness to rob her of her youth & beauty & diphtheria was just a common one (& one that wasn't necessarily lethal) at the time...especially since she also couldn't have caught it by getting wet while sailing...


all the world loves a lover, except the people they were married to when they met each other...

reply

Well, i do know if you're very sick, you can lose almost all your hair. Your hair isn't necessary for survival, so the body shuts down the blood supply to divert the energy to the vital organs.

Two months or so after a serious operation or illness, you can have a major hair fallout.

reply

Diphtheria (Greek(diphthera)"pair of leather scrolls") is an upper respiratory tract illness characterized by sore throat, low fever, and an adherent membrane (a pseudomembrane) on the tonsils, pharynx, and/or nasal cavity. A milder form of diphtheria can be restricted to the skin. It is caused by Corynebacterium diphtheriae, an aerobic Gram-positive bacterium.

The cutaneous form of diphtheria is often a secondary infection of a preexisting skin disease. Signs of cutaneous diphtheria infection develop an average of seven days after the appearance of the primary skin disease. Their was no vacination or antibiotic available until after war.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diphtheria
Wikipedia entry features image of grotesque lesion;therefore, the scars resulting from Fannie's illness is credible afterall.

reply

May be odd to thank you some eight years later, but - that was very informative. Thanks!

_______________

Nothing to see here, move along.

reply

Diphtheria (Greek(diphthera)"pair of leather scrolls") is an upper respiratory tract illness characterized by sore throat, low fever, and an adherent membrane (a pseudomembrane) on the tonsils, pharynx, and/or nasal cavity.[cause of neck swelling] A milder form of diphtheria can be restricted to the skin.

The cutaneous[skin] form of diphtheria is often a secondary infection of a preexisting skin disease. Signs of cutaneous diphtheria infection develop an average of seven days after the appearance of the primary skin disease.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diphtheria
Wikipedia entry features image of grotesque lesion;therefore, the scars resulting from Fannie's illness is credible afterall. Overexposure during sailing could have lowered her resistance to infection, making her vulnerable to an infectious disease that was very popular at the time. Since their was no vacination or antibiotic available until after WWII, she would have been lucky to have survived.

Hope to have given some resolution. Maybe we can enjoy the great performance even better without doubts of authenticity.

reply

Though the illness was named, I just took it for another of those Mysterious Hollywood Diseases. The symptoms are dictated by plot necessity. Bette was prone to these ailments, like the one in 'Dark Victory' that entails an exact prediction of when she will die that is only known to her.

Another good one was whatever Sandy Dennis had in 'Sweet November.'

In 'Skeffington', Bette had to lose her looks, and they did not have ugly sticks back then (as in "Who hit you with an ugly stick?"). I thought smallpox would have been more credible [EDIT: small pox would have been an anachronism in the 20th Century]. Diphtheria is a stretch because it is not commonly associated with long term disfigurement. Maybe a car accident, à la 'Vanilla Sky/Abre los ojos.'

reply