MovieChat Forums > The Lodger (1944) Discussion > Possible goof, or explained in a missing...

Possible goof, or explained in a missing scene?


When the Scotland Yard men are discussing the murder of Annie Rowley with the cast of Kitty's show , her Uncle Robert, played by Sir Cedric Hardwicke, asks grumpily, " Why doesn't someone shoot him?"
Inspector Warwick (George Sanders) answers that not even the police are allowed to carry firearms.

But, near the climax, when the lodger has cornered Kitty in her dressing room and confessed his love/hate obsession to her, and she realizes that he is Jack the Ripper, her screams of terror bring the police running, and Inspector Warwick fires several shots from a revolver at the fleeing murderer, wounding but not killing him.

Could there have been a cut scene where the head of Scotland Yard announces that due to the extraordinary situation, the police will be allowed to carry guns until the Ripper is captured or killed? Did the writer simply forget the earlier dialogue? Is Inspector Warwick so desperate to protect Kitty that he's actually breaking the law?

Any thoughts?


And when he crossed the bridge, the phantoms came to meet him

reply

It is my understanding that, in the nineteenth century, London police were generally armed but that, by the 1930s, a policeman carried a firearm only pursuant to a Sergeant's approval and with proper training, which was uncommon.

Notwithstanding the Inspector's rather poor aim and mulitple stray shots in the presence of many innocent civilians, perhaps he was considered properly trained and thus had been issued a firearm. I did not notice any other police with firearams.

reply

The Police have certain men authorized to carry weapons in very dangerous situations. They have special training. In 1911 Latvian Revolutionaries carried out a jewel robbery to finance their activities in London. Several police officers went to where they thought the gang might be and were mowed down in a hail of bullets. The gang was more heavily armed than the police department who had to send for old pistols from storage.

Winston Churchill went to the scene and called for the Scots Guards. A bullet went through his hat from the revolutionaires. It became known as the Siege of Sidney Street and was made into a movie later. Hitchcock also used the siege in his first version of The Man Who Knew Too Much. The Scots Guards joined the police using rifles.

Only two members of the gang died at the scene. The building caught fire and they wouldn't come out and perhaps committed suicide. Churchill got criticism from political enemies who complained that he refused to let the fire brigade fight the fire. At least they weren't shot at by die hard terrorists.

reply

The two responders above have missed your point. Regardless of the realites of whether the English police of the time actually carried arms and under what circumstances, in the film George Snaders' character clearly says they do not carry guns, and then, without explanation, he draws a pistol and begins firing away at the "Ripper." Counts as a bona-fide goof in my book.

Cheerio!

Fighting for Truth, Justice, and making it the American way.

reply